The control by Na+/H+ antiporters of sodium/proton concentration and cell volume is crucial for the viability of all cells. Adaptation to high salinity and/or extreme pH in plants and bacteria or in human heart muscles requires the action of Na+/H+ antiporters. Their activity is tightly controlled by pH. Here we present the crystal structure of pH-downregulated NhaA, the main antiporter of Escherichia coli and many enterobacteria. A negatively charged ion funnel opens to the cytoplasm and ends in the middle of the membrane at the putative ion-binding site. There, a unique assembly of two pairs of short helices connected by crossed, extended chains creates a balanced electrostatic environment. We propose that the binding of charged substrates causes an electric imbalance, inducing movements, that permit a rapid alternating-access mechanism. This ion-exchange machinery is regulated by a conformational change elicited by a pH signal perceived at the entry to the cytoplasmic funnel.

Using an electrophysiological assay the activity of NhaA was tested in a wide pH range from pH 5.0 to 9.5. Forward and reverse transport directions were investigated at zero membrane potential using preparations with inside-out and right side-out-oriented transporters with Na+ or H+ gradients as the driving force. Under symmetrical pH conditions with a Na+ gradient for activation, both the wt and the pH-shifted G338S variant exhibit highly symmetrical transport activity with bell-shaped pH dependences, but the optimal pH was shifted 1.8 pH units to the acidic range in the variant. In both strains the pH dependence was associated with a systematic increase of the Km for Na+ at acidic pH. Under symmetrical Na+ concentration with a pH gradient for NhaA activation, an unexpected novel characteristic of the antiporter was revealed; rather than being down-regulated, it remained active even at pH as low as 5. These data allowed a transport mechanism to advance based on competing Na+ and H+ binding to a common transport site and a kinetic model to develop quantitatively explaining the experimental results. In support of these results, both alkaline pH and Na+ induced the conformational change of NhaA associated with NhaA cation translocation as demonstrated here by trypsin digestion. Furthermore, Na+ translocation was found to be associated with the displacement of a negative charge. In conclusion, the electrophysiological assay allows the revelation of the mechanism of NhaA antiport and sheds new light on the concept of NhaA pH regulation.

The nhaA gene of Escherichia coli, which encodes a pH-activated Na+/H+ antiporter, has been modified; six of its eight histidine codons were mutated to arginine codons by site-directed mutagenesis, yielding the mutations H254R-H257R (a double mutant), H226R, H39R, H244R, and H319R. In addition a deletion (delta nhaA1-14) lacking the remaining two histidines, His-3 and His-5, has been constructed. By comparing the phenotypes conferred by plasmids bearing the various mutations to the phenotype of the wild type upon transformation of strains NM81 (delta nhaA) or EP432 (delta nhaA, delta nhaB) we found that none of the NhaA histidines are essential for the Na+/H+ antiporter activity of the NhaA protein. However, the replacement of His-226 by Arg markedly changes the pH dependence of the antiporter. All mutants except H226R confer to NM81 and EP432 Na+ resistance up to pH 8.5 as well as Li+ resistance. Cells bearing H226R are resistant to Li+ and to Na+ at neutral pH, but they become sensitive to Na+ above pH 7.5. Analysis of the Na+/H+ antiporter activity of membrane vesicles derived from H226R cells shows that the mutated protein is activated by pH to the same extent as the wild type. However, whereas the activation of the wild-type NhaA occurs between pH 7 and pH 8, that of H226R antiporter occurs between pH 6.5 and pH 7.5. Furthermore, while the wild-type antiporter remains almost fully active at least up to pH 8.5, H226R is reversibly inactivated above pH 7.5, reaching 10-20% of the maximal activity at pH 8.5. We suggest that His-226 is part of a pH-sensitive site that regulates the activity of NhaA.

Cysteine residues were found nonessential in the mechanism of the NhaA antiporter activity of Escherichia coli. The functional C-less NhaA has provided the groundwork to study further histidine 225 of NhaA which has previously been suggested to play an important role in the activation of NhaA at alkaline pH (Rimon, A., Gerchman, Y., Olami, Y., Schuldiner, S. and Padan, E. (1995) J. Biol. Chem. 270, 26813-26817). C-less H225C was constructed and shown to possess an antiporter activity 60% of that of C-less antiporter and a pH profile similar to that of both the C-less or wild-type antiporters. Remarkably, whereas neither the wild-type nor the C-less antiporters were affected by N-ethylmaleimide, C-less H225C was inhibited by this reagent. To determine the degree of alkylation of the antiporter protein by N-ethylmaleimide, antiporter derivatives tagged at their C termini with six histidines residues were constructed. Alkylation of C-less H225C was measured by labeling of everted membrane vesicles with [14 C]N-ethylmaleimide, affinity purification of the His-tagged antiporter, and determination of the radioactivity of the purified protein. This assay showed that H225C is alkylated to a much higher level than any of the native cysteinyl residues of NhaA reaching saturation at alkyl/ NhaA stoichiometry of 1. The wild-type derivative showed at least 10-fold less alkylation even at higher concentrations, suggesting that H225C resides in a domain that is much more exposed to N-ethylmaleimide than the native cysteinyl residues of NhaA.Since H225C residues both in right-side out and inside-out membrane vesicles were quantitatively alkylated by N-ethylmaleimide, this assay was used to determine the accessibility of H225C to other SH reagents by titrating the H225C left free to react with N-ethylmaleimide, following exposure of the membranes to the reagents. Furthermore, since membrane-impermeant probes can react with residues in membrane-embedded protein only if accessible to the medium containing the reagent, the assay was used to determine the membrane topology of H225C.As expected for a membrane-permeant probe, p-chloromercuribenzoate reacted with H225C as efficiently as N-ethylmaleimide in both membrane orientations. Similar results were obtained with methanethiosulfonate ethylammonium supporting the recent observations that this probe is membrane-permeant. On the other hand, both membrane-impermeant reagents p-chloromercuribenzosulfonate and methanethiosulfonate ethyl-trimethyl ammonium bromide reacted with H225C 10-fold more in right-side out than in inside-out vesicles, and p-chloromercuribenzosulfonate also blocked completely the H225C in intact cells. These results strongly suggest that H225C is exposed at the periplasmic face of the membrane.

Cation/proton antiporters (CPAs) play a major role in maintaining living cells’ homeostasis. CPAs are commonly divided into two main groups, CPA1 and CPA2, and are further characterized by two main phenotypes: ion selectivity and electrogenicity. However, tracing the evolutionary relationships of these transporters is challenging because of the high diversity within CPAs. Here, we conduct comprehensive evolutionary analysis of 6537 representative CPAs, describing the full complexity of their phylogeny, and revealing a sequence motif that appears to determine central phenotypic characteristics. In contrast to previous suggestions, we show that the CPA1/CPA2 division only partially correlates with electrogenicity. Our analysis further indicates two acidic residues in the binding site that carry the protons in electrogenic CPAs, and a polar residue in the unwound transmembrane helix 4 that determines ion selectivity. A rationally designed triple mutant successfully converted the electrogenic CPA, EcNhaA, to be electroneutral.