An unprecedented behavior of ortho-sulfinylpropargyl carbanions in the presence of optically active sulfinylimines affords two different families of compounds: this peculiar chemodivergency is importantly affected by the nature of the employed base, and assisted by the configuration of the electrophile, displaying no alteration in the stereocontrol of both reactions. α-Allenylamines are formed exclusively, using R-sulfinyl aldimines as electrophiles, while homopropargylamines result when S-sulfinyl aldimines are employed.