Plain radiographs of the cervical spine lack sensitivity to detect the presence of lateral mass/ facet fractures. The appearance of the fracture on computed tomography does not indicate instability. The degree of ligamentous injury at the level of the fracture demonstrated on magnetic resonance imaging correlates with instability in this series. Operative stabilization may be indicated for unilateral lateral mass fractures that present with a subluxation or that have injury to at least three of the following ligaments: the facet region, the interspinous ligament, the anterior longitudinal ligament, and the posterior longitudinal ligament. However, before a definitive management plan can be formulated, results from this small series require further validation.