Background: Adult phenylketonuria (PKU) patients often reduce their intake of amino acid mixture (AAM) to less than the prescribed amounts. Effects of reduced AAM intake on nutrient supply were evaluated. Methods: Nutrient intake was calculated in 20 adult PKU patients based on a structured food record and complemented by laboratory assessment of nutritional status. Patients were classified into 2 groups, (A) regular AAM intake, or (B) AAM intake below calculated requirements. Results: Group B consumed a higher proportion of natural protein (60 ± 23 vs. 33 ± 12%, p = 0.002); however, the total protein intake was below the recommended amounts in 60% of patients in group B versus 7% in group A (p = 0.03). Fat intake was higher in group B (39 ± 9% of energy vs. 31 ± 6%, p = 0.03), mainly from saturated fats. Selenium, folate, and vitamin B12 intake was below the recommended intake in group B. However, serum concentrations of these analytes remained within the normal range in both groups, although vitamin B12 levels were lower in group B. Plasma tyrosine correlated with AAM intake, and hydroxyproline correlated with the amount of natural protein consumed. Conclusion: Relaxed AAM intake resulted in insufficient nutrient supply, despite a compensatory increase in consumption of natural protein. Care needs to be taken to ensure adequate nutrition in adults with PKU.