Household hazardous waste (HHW) continues to be a growing problem in the United States of America (USA), and globally. Disposing of HHW is important when protecting human health and the environment. Recycling HHW has many benefits including reducing contact with hazardous pollutants. This study describes participants in a HHW recycling program in a small southern community in the USA, and factors that influence their participation. This HHW Recycling Day collects (potentially) harmful substances from citizens for proper disposal. A 28 item questionnaire was completed by 145 participants. The top hazardous items recycled were paint, electronic waste, and batteries. Individuals who were retired were more likely to recycle and felt more confident about properly managing HHW. Men and participants with a college degree were more likely to recycle HHW. Educating the public regarding HHW disposal is essential. Funding such programs may increase community awareness.