The compensatory growth, productive performance, proximal composition and somatic indices of Nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus) cultivated in biofloc were evaluated during a 144‐day period under five cyclic regimes of feed restriction and feeding. Five treatment groups, in which the frequency of feed restriction (R) and feeding (F) varied by periods (days) as follows: R1:F3, R3:F9, R6:F18, R8:F24 and R12:F36; each treatment was evaluated in triplicate. The cycles were repeated throughout the culture period. The control group received feed daily. Fish were cultivated in 18 circular tanks (3 m3) at a density of 50 fish/m3 per tank. At the end of the study, the survival of Nile tilapia was greater than 90% in all the treatments. Complete compensation in growth was achieved in R6:F18 and R12:F36. At the end of the feed restriction period, both crude protein and total lipid content of the tilapia muscle tissue taken from fish of the treatment groups were similar to samples of muscle tissue derived from fish of the control group; however, a reduction of more than 40% in somatic indices compared with the control was observed, but these recovered by the end of the feeding phase. The results indicate that cyclic feeding based on 12 days of feed restriction and 36 days of feeding (R12:F36) induced a complete compensation in weight and restoration of energy reserves, with similar measures of productive performance observed when compared to the control treatment during the culture of Nile tilapia in biofloc, and food reduction did not affect proximal composition.