Background: Three novel heterozygous SF-1 gene mutations affecting multiple members of two unrelated families with a history of 46,XY disorders of sex development (DSD) and 46,XX ovarian insufficiency are described. Methods: Clinical and mutational analysis of the SF-1 gene in 9 subjects of two families. Results: Family 1 had 2 affected 46,XY DSD subjects. One, born with severe perineal hypospadias, was raised as a male, and presented normal adolescence. The other, born with ambiguous genitalia, uterus, and mild testicular dysgenesis, was raised as a female. A W279X heterozygous mutation and an intronic deletion (g3314-3317delTCTC (IVS 4 + 8) was found in the SF-1 gene. In family 2, 4/6 affected siblings had 46,XY DSD or hypospadias. An affected 46,XX sister had normal sexual development but increased FSH levels. The 37-year-old affected mother had entered menopause. An Y183X heterozygous mutation was detected. Conclusion: An extreme within-family phenotypic variability, ranging from severe prenatal undervirilization to normal pubertal development, was observed in 46,XY-affected siblings, indicating that other unknown factors might be involved in the phenotype. Low ovarian reserve and preserved fertility in 46,XX subjects can be observed in heterozygous SF-1 gene mutations.

Sex determination in mammals is governed by antagonistic interactions of two genetic pathways, imbalance in which may lead to disorders/differences of sex development (DSD) in human. Among 46,XX individuals with testicular DSD (TDSD) or ovotesticular DSD (OTDSD), testicular tissue is present in the gonad. Although the testis-determining geneSRYis present in many cases, the etiology is unknown in mostSRY-negative patients. We performed exome sequencing on 78 individuals with 46,XX TDSD/OTDSD of unknown genetic etiology and identified seven (8.97%) with heterozygous variants affecting the fourth zinc finger (ZF4) of Wilms’ tumor 1 (WT1) (p.Ser478Thrfs*17, p.Pro481Leufs*15, p.Lys491Glu, p.Arg495Gln [x3], p.Arg495Gly). The variants were de novo in six families (P= 4.4 × 10−6), and the incidence of WT1 variants in 46,XX DSD is enriched compared to control populations (P< 1.8 × 10−4). The introduction of ZF4 mutants into a human granulosa cell line resulted in up-regulation of endogenous Sertoli cell transcripts andWt1Arg495Gly/Arg495GlyXX mice display masculinization of the fetal gonads. The phenotype could be explained by the ability of the mutated proteins to physically interact with and sequester a key pro-ovary factor β-CATENIN, which may lead to up-regulation of testis-specific pathway. Our data show that unlike previous association of WT1 and 46,XY DSD, ZF4 variants of WT1 are a relatively common cause of 46,XX TDSD/OTDSD. This expands the spectrum of phenotypes associated with WT1 variants and shows that the WT1 protein affecting ZF4 can function as a protestis factor in an XX chromosomal context.

In humans, steroidogenic factor 1 (NR5A1/SF-1) mutations have been reported to cause gonadal dysgenesis, with or without adrenal failure, in both 46,XY and 46,XX individuals. We have previously reported extreme within-family variability in affected 46,XY patients. Even though low ovarian reserve with preserved fertility has been reported in females harboring NR5A1 gene mutations, fertility has only been observed in one reported case in affected 46,XY individuals. A kindred with multiple affected members presenting gonadal dysgenesis was studied. Four 46,XY individuals presented severe hypospadias at birth, one of them associated with micropenis and cryptorchidism. The other 3 developed spontaneous male puberty, and 1 has fathered 5 children. Four 46,XX patients presented premature ovarian failure (one of them was not available for the study) or high follicle-stimulating hormone levels. Mutational analysis of the NR5A1 gene revealed a novel heterozygous mutation, c.938G→A, predicted to cause a p.Arg313Hys amino acid change. A highly conserved amino acid of the ligand-binding domain of the mature protein is affected, predicting abnormal protein function. We confirm that preserved fertility can be observed in patients with a 46,XY disorder of sex development due to heterozygous mutations in the NR5A1 gene.

No abstract

Increased knowledge on phenotypical variability found in female aromatase-deficient patients is useful to improve the detection rate in this disorder. In our population, a genetic founder defect has probably contributed to an increase in the incidence of the c.628G>A splice mutation.