Spongospora subterranea is a soil-borne plasmodiophorid that causes powdery scab and root gall formation in potato. In this study, eighteen cover crops suitable for use in dry, high-altitude potato production regions were assessed in potting mix trials to determine whether these cover crops altered S. subterranea population levels. Although S. subterranea appeared to invade roots of all plant species tested, the pathogen was unable to complete its life cycle on eleven of eighteen cover crops based on post-harvest qPCR and microscopy results. Buckwheat, legumes, and scarlet-barley do not appear to support pathogen replication, but the pathogen may be able to complete its life cycle in some mustards. High variability occurred in the experiments and part of this may be due to the natural infestations of peat-based potting mix with S. subterranea. A tomato bioassay was used to confirm that commercial sources of peat-based potting mix were infested with S. subterranea. Dry heat and autoclaving were tested as sanitation methods and multiple rounds of autoclaving were required to reduce viable S. subterranea in potting mix. A second cover crop experiment with autoclaved potting mix was conducted and it confirmed that buckwheat, legumes, and barley do not support S. subterranea replication but that some brassica crops may be hosts of this pathogen. The results suggest that buckwheat, legumes, and barley pose the least risk as cover crops in S. subterranea infested fields and show that peat-based potting mix should not be used in seed potato production.