Monogenic diseases can often manifest diverse clinical phenotypes and cause diagnostic dilemmas. While monoallelic loss-of-function variants in TNFAIP3 (Haploinsufficiency of A20; HA20) cause a highly penetrant autoinflammatory disease, the variable expressivity suggest a role for additional genetic and environmental disease modifiers. Here, we identify critically ill children who inherited a family-specific TNFAIP3 deletion from one of their otherwise healthy parents. Each of the probands also inherited in trans a subtle loss-of-function I207L TNFAIP3 variant that is common in Oceania, originally introgressed from Denisovans. Modelling this compound heterozgous state in mice under specific pathogen free conditions demonstrated a reduced threshold to break immune tolerance. Exaggerated immune responses were precipitated by inheriting the two genetic hits on the TNFAIP3 checkpoint coupled with increasing the microbial challenge to immune tolerance, either by co-housing with pet store mice carrying a wild microbial burden or by transient dietary exposure to a chemical that diminishes the intestinal mucin barrier separating gut microbes from immune sensing systems. These data illuminate second-hit genetic and environmental modifiers contributing to complex inflammatory and autoimmune disease. Increased mechanistic understanding of the presence and contribution of disease modifiers will aid diagnostic and prognostic patient stratification and potentially reveal novel therapeutic opportunities.