The performance of heifers from a Brahman herd that was selected for fertility was compared with Brahman heifers sourced from commercial properties using three year-groups of heifers. Each year, conception rates from yearling mating were significantly higher in heifers from the selected herd (SEL) than in heifers sourced from commercial properties (COM), despite the average joining weight of the SEL heifers being lower each year. The pregnancy rate in SEL heifers was 24% higher (P = 0.008) in the first year, 36% higher (P = 0.005) in the second year and 45% higher (P < 0.001) in the third year. Over the 3 years of the study, the conception rate was 35% higher (P = 0.009) in SEL heifers than in COM heifers. Joining weight also affected pregnancy rates. When heifers were split into weight ranges according to their pre-joining weight, pregnancy rates were significantly higher (P = 0.018) in the heavier weight range than the lighter one. The results indicate that selection for fertility has been successful in improving conception rates from yearling mating in SEL heifers.