Introduction Diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) is being increasingly used during brain tumor surgery. However, there is limited data available on its diagnostic and prognostic value. Our objective was to assess the pattern of involvement of white matter tracts (WMTs) by intra-axial brain tumors on DTI. Secondary objectives were to evaluate implications of involvement of WMT on surgical resection, and the post-operative functional outcome. Methods This was a retrospective study of consecutive patients, who underwent DTI-guided surgery for brain tumors. The involvement of WMTs by tumors on DTI was assessed by a radiologist (who was blind to the pathology) using the Witwer classification. The pathology was reported by histopathologists using the World Health Organization brain tumor classification. Karnofsky Performance Status Scale (KPS) was used for assessing patients’ neurological status at admission, and at follow-up. Results Forty-five (58.4%) out of 77 tumors reviewed caused infiltration of WMTs, whereas only 22 (28.6%) tumors caused displacement of WMTs (p= 0.040). Among 32 cases of astrocytoma, the involvement of WMTs was influenced by the grade of tumor (p= 0.012), as high-grade tumors caused infiltration (19; 59.4%), unlike low-grade tumors that commonly caused displacement (2; 50%). Oligodendrogliomas caused infiltration/disruption of WMTs in most cases, irrespective of the grade (19 out of 25 cases; 76%). At the last follow-up, 27 (35.1%) patients showed improvement in KPS and 14 (18.2%) reported deterioration, while there was no change observed in 36 (46.8%) patients. The infiltration of WMTs was associated with a poor functional outcome. Conclusions High-grade astrocytomas mostly cause infiltration of WMTs, unlike oligodendrogliomas, which often infiltrate WMTs, irrespective of the tumor grade. The infiltration of WMTs is associated with a poor functional outcome at follow-ups.