This chapter examines how mentoring pre-tenured and tenured faculty during organizational change of implementing fully online academic programs impacts resistant and/or supportive faculty. By using a case of an experience of some faculty at HBCUs, the authors examine how mentorship is necessary to engender a supportive and successful transition in the face of faculty members' resistance to including online education. Influence on faculty becoming adept experts of online teaching and education, prioritizing online teaching and its impact on how they approach live instruction, and anticipating how a designated mentor(s) affects teaching evaluations and research scholarship necessary to achieve rank and tenure promotion will be delineated.