The mechanism of nitrogenase, the enzyme responsible for biological nitrogen fixation, has been of great interest for understanding the catalytic strategy utilized to reduce dinitrogen to ammonia under ambient temperatures and pressures. The reduction mechanism of nitrogenase is generally envisioned as involving multiple cycles of electron and proton transfers, with the known substrates requiring at least two cycles. Solvent kinetic isotope effect experiments, in which changes of reaction rates or product distribution are measured upon enrichment of solvent with heavy atom isotopes, have been valuable for deciphering the mechanism of complex enzymatic reactions involving proton or hydrogen transfer. We report the distribution of ethylene, dihydrogen, and methane isotopologue products measured from nitrogenase-catalyzed reductions of acetylene, protons, and cyanide, respectively, performed in varying levels of deuterium enrichment of the solvent. As has been noted previously, the total rate of product formation by nitrogenase is largely insensitive to the presence of D 2 O in the solvent. Nevertheless, the incorporation of H/D into products can be measured for these substrates that reflect solvent isotope effects on hydrogen atom transfers that are faster than the overall rate-determining step for nitrogenase. From these data, a minimal isotope effect is observed for acetylene reduction (1.4 ± 0.05), while the isotope effects for hydrogen and methane evolution are significantly higher at 4.2 ± 0.1 and 4.4 ± 0.1, respectively. These results indicate that there are pronounced differences in the sensitivity to isotopic substitution of the hydrogen atom transfer steps associated with the reduction of these substrates by nitrogenase.