A comparative study of patients’ satisfaction with different levels of hospitals in Beijing: why do patients prefer high-level hospitals?

Abstract

Background: To promote the integration of medical resources, Beijing has built medical alliances since 2012, but this reform has not changed the state of disordered medical treatment. Patients are still willing to go to high-level hospitals for medical treatment. What causes patients to prefer high-level hospitals? To explore the reasons behind this preference for high-level medical treatment among patients and to guide patients to make visits in an orderly manner, we conducted this study and compared patients' satisfaction with hospitals of different levels in the context of medical resource integration. Methods: This study conducted a questionnaire survey among 1250 patients who were selected in 18 medical alliances in Beijing from October to December 2016. The study type is a comparative study based on cross-sectional data. Patient satisfaction was the main outcome, and descriptive analysis, chi-square tests, nonparametric tests and binary logistic regression analysis were used. The level of statistical significance was set at p < 0.05. Results: The overall satisfaction score of the medical alliances was 3.375, and the satisfaction scores of core hospitals and cooperative hospitals were 2.77 and 3.07, respectively. The overall patient satisfaction rate was 44.62%, and the satisfaction rates of core hospitals and cooperative hospitals were 34.34 and 50.43%, respectively. The type of hospital and understanding of medical alliance policy were the factors associated with patient satisfaction with the medical alliance. Conclusions: The patients' satisfaction with cooperative hospitals was higher than their satisfaction with core hospitals. Although the patients were more satisfied with the service attitude of the cooperative hospitals, they still preferred core hospitals due to their higher expectations for their medical treatment and greater trust in their medical technology. It is necessary to explore the establishment of closed medical alliances under the unified management of human and financial resources to enable medical alliances to become a community of common interests and provide integrated medical services for patients.

Impacts of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Public Hospitals of Different Levels: Six-Month Evidence from Shanghai, China

“…Because of the enormous reduction during the first half of 2020, tertiary hospitals have more supply capacity to provide services to additional patients, who prefer to seek care in higher-level and larger hospitals. [42][43][44] Third, tertiary hospitals may have induced a demand for patients to make up for their losses during the pandemic. Tertiary hospitals are believed to provide high-quality medical care and have a better reputation among Chinese residents.…”

COVID-19 as an opportunity to reveal the impact of large hospital expansion on the healthcare delivery system: evidence from Shanghai, China

“…It remains us to reconsider the rationality of the market share of the healthcare delivery system in China. Under normal conditions, most patients in China prefer to visit large hospitals even for common and minor illnesses, as they can freely choose which doctors and medical institutions to visit (18,19,35). These might be due to the COVID-19 pandemic increasing the care-seeking cost of large hospitals, which may include the risk of being infected and transportation convenience (18).…”

“…The shift was more substantial for discharge services and surgery services. This may have occurred due to patients being more likely to choose larger hospitals when they needed more complex treatment (18,35). This means the patients might be more likely to choose larger hospitals for conditions perceived to be nonminor diseases.…”

“…This means the patients might be more likely to choose larger hospitals for conditions perceived to be nonminor diseases. As there was no strict referral system and a lax medical insurance restriction, the patients can choose which doctors and medical institutions to visit freely (18,19,35). Before the pandemic, the large hospitals in China were always crowded, and some patients left these hospitals due to this crowding (3).…”

What Truly Matters for The Implementation of Medical Alliances? A Cross-Sectional Study in China From The Perspective of Physicians

“…All physicians with senior titles in CHC were surveyed, and 50% of the physicians with intermediate and junior titles were selected for this study. 22,23 , this study included the four most important indexes from the evaluation index system as the evaluation indexes of MAs in this study: Degree of improvement in community residents' satisfaction, improvement in primary diagnosis at CHC and two-way referral, evaluation of information construction and evaluation of mutual recognition of medical examination results.…”