A Comparison of Two Studies of the Pressure Distribution under the Feet of Normal Subjects Using Different Equipment

Abstract

There is growing interest in the use of foot pressure measurement both clinically and in the study of normal subjects. A number of systems are now commercially available, but comparison of the results is complicated by the different techniques employed. This paper compares the results of two studies. The first examined a large group of normal subjects using the dynamic pedobarograph. The second was identical to the first except that the EMED F system was used. The second study was carried out in order to verify existing results and to assess the clinical significance of the expected differences. Comparison of the results from the two studies showed that the median peak pressures demonstrated similar patterns with the highest pressure in the forefoot under the second/third metatarsal heads and the toes taking gradually reduced pressure from the first to the fifth toe. The EMED F showed higher peak pressures than the dynamic pedobarograph under the heel, the medial four metatarsal heads, and the great toe and showed lower peak pressures and shorter contact times under the lateral four toes. The pattern of loading across the metatarsal heads was further analyzed using an objective method of splitting the subjects into groups. Four groups were isolated from both sets of results, and this has confirmed that only a proportion of normal subjects demonstrate highest loading under the first metatarsal head whereas the remainder show highest loading centrally within the forefoot.

Foot Symmetry and Plantar Pressure Characteristics in Elite Taekwondo Athletes; Preferred and Non-Preferred Foot Comparison

“…The highest PP values were found under the M2, M3, M4 heads and heel zones at both feet. These findings are in agreement with the studies of Bryant et al and Hughes et al 33,37 Metatarsalgia may occur as a result of repetitive loading on metatarsal heads. Unbalanced distribution of load may be a reason of stress fractures and may lead to high pressure on metatarsal heads.…”

Inter- and intra-observer reliability of masking in plantar pressure measurement analysis

“…In gait analysis research, data are often pooled across three or five steps in order to produce mean values (ensemble averages); and represent an international accepted method to partially overcome the step-to-step variation of human gait [24]. We further explored the value of ensemble averaging to increase the robustness of the data analysis concerning inter-observer agreement.…”

Fraturas intra-articulares do calcâneo: análise clínica e biomecânica

“…Segundo Hughes et al (42) , o coeficiente de confiança aumentava à medida que se utilizava o maior número de passos na coleta de dados e trabalhava-se com os dados das médias das pressões. Em função da grande variabilidade dos dados biológicos, utilizamos, como parâmetro do valor que expressa a variável cinética, a média das três melhores passada (as que apresentam menor desvio padrão).…”