A Literature Review of Barriers and Opportunities Presented by Digitally Enhanced Practical Skill Teaching and Learning in Health Science Education

Abstract

Introduction An evidence gap exists identifying the challenges and opportunities presented by digitally enhanced practical skill teaching and learning in health science education. A literature review was carried out to address this gap and to provide recommendations for overcoming identified challenges. Method A systematic search strategy was carried out using PRISMA guidelines. The research databases PubMed, ERIC, Medline and CINHL, were searched using MeSH terms. Barriers and opportunities were identified through deductive thematic analysis of the included articles. Results Of the 602 articles identified through the database screening, 29 were included in the current review. Potential challenges posed by technologically supported practical skill teaching identified were i) Inaccessibility and Inequity of Online Learning (ii) Digital illiteracy Among Staff (iii) Technological Challenges (iv) Lack of Engagement with Preparatory Material Hinders Practical Learning (v) Lack of Staff–Student Interaction (vi) Negative Attitudes Towards Online Learning and (vii) Skill Suitability. The opportunities presented by digital technologies identified were (i) Facilitates Higher Order Learning (ii) Ability to Practice in a Safe Environment (iii) Efficacious Use of Class Time (iv) Access to Education (v) Learning Brought to Life (vi) Diverse Range of Learning Materials (vii) Promotes Autonomous Learning. Discussion This literature review demonstrates the acceptability and usability of digitally enhanced practical teaching in health science education among students and educators. Conclusion To consolidate the positive disturbances in higher education from the Covid-19 pandemic, potential barriers to online delivery and student engagement must be acknowledged and addressed by relevant stakeholders. Recommendations detailed as part of this paper suggest means of overcoming barriers and leveraging opportunities.

Evaluating the effect of online surgical education on intraoperative cholangiogram interpretation: a pilot study

“…10,11 The driver of this IOC online initiative stemmed initially from necessity when Coronavirus 2019 was first declared a global pandemic, when global emergency lockdowns resulted in university and hospital closures together with social distancing measures introduced to reduce the spread of the virus, and a suspension of numerous face-to-face teaching. 12 This abrupt shift in teaching methods presented novel challenges for surgical educators necessitating adjustments to practical skills teaching and a pivot towards online delivery programs. Online learning is now a fundamental component of medical education worldwide and the growth trend for surgical trainees participating in online courses is also expected to expand.…”

“…Accordingly, we did not assess socioeconomic and environmental factors, for example, regional versus city hospitals, which may reduce accessibility to online learning because of unsuitable home environments, financial demand on surgical trainees in having essential learning equipment, and poor internet access. All these factors have been reported to be potential barriers to online educational initiatives 12 . Finally, our educators' lack of familiarity and experience with digitally enhanced online teaching methods may also have resulted in a low‐quality design and delivery of learning materials, hindering surgical trainee interaction, engagement, and overall learning.…”

“…All these factors have been reported to be potential barriers to online educational initiatives. 12 Finally, our educators' lack of familiarity and experience with digitally enhanced online teaching methods may also have resulted in a low-quality design and delivery of learning materials, hindering surgical trainee interaction, engagement, and overall learning. As practical skills teaching often focuses on visual, tactile and auditory information, poor quality of online audio and/or visual resources may have been frustrating for learners.…”

The Application of Virtual Tools in Teaching Dynamics in Engineering

“…While developing effective visualisations for learning one should be aware of to the limitation of cognitive architecture, taking into consideration level of learner expertise. Moreover, visualisation needs to be constructed to maximise learning, and minimise confusion by incorporating principles of good multimedia design, using contemporary learning practice, approaches and research [23][24][25]. This includes presenting information in a scaffolded way and allowing for accessibility.…”

Knowledge acquisition efficacy of a remote flipped classroom on learning about removable partial dentures

“…The coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic led to the use of remote education in a learning management system (LMS) [1], which has prompted an evaluation of the effectiveness of such a broad digital learning approach [2]. Online learning, which included synchronous or asynchronous teaching materials, worked better than traditional classroom teaching in enhancing undergraduate medical students' knowledge and skill outcomes [3].…”