A Participatory Intervention to Improve the Psychosocial Work Environment and Mental Health in Human Service Organisations. A Mixed Methods Evaluation Study

Abstract

Work-related stress is a global problem causing suffering and economic costs. In Sweden, employees in human service occupations are overrepresented among persons on sick leave due to mental health problems such as stress-related disorders. The psychosocial work environment is one contributing factor for this problem, making it urgent to identify effective methods to decrease stress at the workplace. The aim of the study is to evaluate a participatory intervention to improve the psychosocial work environment and mental health using an embedded mixed methods design. The study is a controlled trial with a parallel process evaluation exploring fidelity and participants’ reactions to the intervention activities, experiences of learning and changes in behaviours and work routines. We collected data through documentation, interviews and three waves of questionnaires. Our results show small changes in behaviours and work routines and no positive effects of the intervention on the psychosocial work environment nor health outcomes. One explanation is end-users’ perceived lack of involvement over the process causing the intervention to be seen as a burden. Another explanation is that the intervention activities were perceived targeting the wrong organisational level. A representative participation over both content and process can be an effective strategy to change psychosocial working conditions and mental health.

Effects of a co-created occupational health intervention on stress and psychosocial working conditions within the construction industry: A controlled trial

“…Accordingly, the unfavorable development of most outcomes in the intervention and control groups appears to be related to factors outside the organisation. Additionally, the enrolled region has not indicated that the intervention was burdensome or demanding, which has been seen in similar studies reporting adverse health effects (39,40). Instead, the participants of the co-creation process perceived the intervention components and the implementation strategy as relevant and well-tailored to the organisation's context (22).…”

Co-Creating an Occupational Health Intervention within the Construction Industry in Sweden: Stakeholder Perceptions of the Process and Output

“…Further, it was also time-efficient to use already scheduled HSB-meetings to discuss questions related to the project. This was a way to make sure the involvement in the co-creation was not seen as a burden, which other studies [ 37 , 38 ] have shown is harmful to the outcomes of an intervention.…”

Empirical Study Dalam Meningkatkan Semangat Kerja Karyawan Pt Eds Manufacturing Indonesia Balaraja-Tangerang

“…Area kegiatan merupakan seluruh kondisi yang terjalin yang berhubungan dengan ikatan kegiatan, bagus ikatan dengan pimpinan ataupun ikatan antara kawan sesama kegiatan, atau ikatan dengan anak buah. Area nonraga seharusnya memantulkan situasi yang mensupport kerjasama antara tingkatan pimpinan, anak buah ataupun yang mempunyai kedudukan yang serupa di perusahaan (Cedstrand, 2021). Lingkungan kerja adalah apa yang terdapat di lingkungan yang dapat mempengaruhi pekerja dalam menjalankan tugasnya, seperti suhu, kelembaban, ventilasi, pencahayaan, kebersihan area aktivitas, dan apakah peralatan aktivitas memadai.…”