A practical hybrid approach to the problem of surveying a working historical bell considering innovative measurement methods

Skrzypczak, Izabela; Oleniacz, Grzegorz; Leśniak, Agnieszka; Mrówczyńska, Maria; Rymar, Marta; Oleksy, Mariusz

doi:10.1186/s40494-023-01007-1

Cited by 5 publications

(4 citation statements)

References 65 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…HBIM is a very useful and effective methodology for the management of historic/cultural heritage sites (Obolewicz and Baryłka, 2021;Obolewicz and Baryłka, 2023), as it provides a documentary basis for further analysis and project development of current and future maintenance, preservation or renovation activities (Rocha et al, 2020, Skrzypczak et al, 2023. The developed models of historical objects should include accurate structural features and information about their transformations and renovations that have taken place.…”

Section: Hbim Modeling Of Cultural Heritage Buildingsmentioning

confidence: 99%

See 1 more Smart Citation

SCAN-TO-BIM method and analysis of measurement accuracy on the example of a historic church

LEŚNIAK,

SKRZYPCZAK,

KRUSZKA

2023

iboa

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Building information modeling (BIM) data for existing buildings based on scans and point clouds acquired from terrestrial laser scanning (TLS) is the basis of the Scan-to-BIM methodology and is becoming common practice. However, work on the accuracy of the resulting model is still desired. The article discusses the possibility of developing a BIM model of a historical building, based on data obtained by terrestrial laser scanning. The subject of the study was the church in Posada Rybotycka (Poland). The mapping reliability studies included PointCab and ReCap point cloud processing, 3D modeling of the object using Revit software, and analysis of the accuracy of distance measurements made by TLS with data obtained from measurements made with traditional methods: total station and laser rangefinder. Based on the conducted research, the possibility of using the BIM with TLS data in the process of reconstructing the geometry of a historic building was evaluated. The results of the study showed that the convergence of the 3D model geometry with the actual course of the structure depends on the development methodology, i.e. the accuracy of 3D data acquisition, the registration process, the filtering procedure, or the parametric structural modeling method used.

show abstract

Section: Hbim Modeling Of Cultural Heritage Buildingsmentioning

confidence: 99%

“…In engineering applications, two measurement methods dominate: contact and non-contact. Of course, the basis for the selection of a measurement method is the cost-effectiveness of its use (cost) and measurement time (Skrzypczak and Leśniak, 2023).…”

Section: Ground-based Measurement Techniquesmentioning

confidence: 99%

SCAN-TO-BIM method and analysis of measurement accuracy on the example of a historic church

LEŚNIAK,

SKRZYPCZAK,

KRUSZKA

2023

iboa

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…-environmental mapping and assessment of the state of the natural environment Chiappini et al (2022), Wężyk et al (2019), Balestra et al (2022), Przewoźna et al (2021), Kovanič e. al. (2020b), Apollo et al (2023), Krok et al (2020); -documentation of cultural heritage Herrero-Tejedor et al (2023), Warchoł and Lęcznar (2022), Sobura et al (2023), Gawronek et al (2017), Liu, et al (2023), Rzonca (2018), Prokop et al (2021), Gawronek and Noszczyk (2023), Bieda et al (2021), Skrzypczak et al (2023); -inventories of building objects to create 3D BIM (Building Information Modeling) models Skrzypczak et al (2022), Colucci et al (2021);…”

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 99%

Selected Qualitative Aspects of Lidar Point Clouds: Geoslam Zeb-Revo and Faro Focus 3d X130

Warchoł,

Karaś,

Antoń

2023

Int. Arch. Photogramm. Remote Sens. Spatial Inf. Sci.

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Abstract. This paper presents a comparison of LiDAR point clouds acquired using two, different measurement techniques: static TLS (Terrestrial Laser Scanning) performed with a FARO Focus3D X130 laser scanner and a SLAM-based (Simultaneous Localization and Mapping) unit of MLS (Mobile Laser Scanning), namely GeoSLAM ZEB-REVO. After the two point clouds were brought into a single coordinate system, they were compared with each other in terms of internal accuracy and density. The density aspect was visualized using 2D density rasters, and calculated using 3 methods available in CloudCompare software. Thus, one should consider before choosing how to acquire a LiDAR point cloud whether a short measurement time is more important (ZEB-REVO) or whether higher density and measurement accuracy is more important (FARO Focus3D X130). In BIM/HBIM modeling applications, logic dictates that the TLS solution should be chosen, despite the longer data acquisition and processing time, but with a cloud with far better quality parameters that allow objects on the point cloud to be recognized. In a situation where the TLS point cloud is 20 times more dense, it allows to model objects at the appropriate level of geometric detail.

show abstract

“…The proper planning of refurbishment work should result from an analysis of repair needs [7][8][9][10]. Decision making related to the selection of the type, scope and date of building repairs is very problematic for managers [11,12]. Algorithms are needed to support decision making for repair work.…”

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 99%

Influence of the Decision to Select Renovated Elements in a Heritage Building on Further Stages of the Aging Process of the Building—A Case Study

Kurowska,

Nowogońska

2023

Sustainability

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

The successful use of buildings requires experience, interdisciplinary knowledge and skills. Wrong decisions made by building owners or managers to implement repair projects have a negative impact on the aging of buildings, which is closely related to sustainable development. Renovation projects in more degraded buildings must be carried out to a greater extent, which has a negative impact on the environment in the form of more building waste. This article presents the results of research on the impact of refurbishment decisions on the technical conditions of buildings. The development of an optimal building renovation strategy will result in a safe and comfortable building. A comparative analysis of the impact of the choice of repair building elements on further aging changes in the building was carried out. The reason for the subject is the frequent consideration by managers of the hierarchy of building elements that improve the technical condition of the building, the reason for which is the lack of financial resources to carry out overall renovation works. To date, two refurbishment strategies have been adopted, as well as assumptions about the building’s material and structural solutions and the building’s service life. Theoretical assumptions were applied to determine the repair needs of the Bialkow palace. The method shows the superiority of the impact of structural elements over non-structural elements in improving the technical condition of a building. Developing a renovation plan with the implementation of the presented strategy will significantly reduce the technical condition of the entire building with a moderate budget, limiting the occurrence of a building disaster and the serious carbon footprint associated with the demolition of the property.

show abstract

A practical hybrid approach to the problem of surveying a working historical bell considering innovative measurement methods

Cited by 5 publications

References 65 publications

SCAN-TO-BIM method and analysis of measurement accuracy on the example of a historic church

SCAN-TO-BIM method and analysis of measurement accuracy on the example of a historic church

Selected Qualitative Aspects of Lidar Point Clouds: Geoslam Zeb-Revo and Faro Focus 3d X130

Influence of the Decision to Select Renovated Elements in a Heritage Building on Further Stages of the Aging Process of the Building—A Case Study

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About