A risk analysis for floods and lahars: case study in the Cordillera Central of Colombia

Abstract

The glacier-covered Nevado del Tolima in the Colombian Cordillera Central is an active volcano with potential lahars that might be more hazardous than those on Nevado del Ruiz. Furthermore, rainfalltriggered floods and landslides notoriously and severely affect the region. For effective disaster prevention, a risk analysis is of primary importance. We present here a risk analysis methodology that is based on the assessment of lahar and rainfall-related flood hazard scenarios and different aspects of vulnerability. The methodology is applied for populated centres in the Combeima valley and the regional capital Ibagué (*500,000 inhabitants). Lahar scenarios of 0.5, 1, 5, and 15 million m3 volume are based on melting of 1, 2, 10, and 25 % of ice, firn and snow, respectively, due to volcanic activity and subsequent lahar formation. For flood modelling, design floods with a return period of 10 and 100 years were calculated. Vulnerability is assessed considering physical vulnerability, operationalized by market values of dwelling parcels and population density, whereas social vulnerability is expressed by the age structure of the population and poverty. Standardization of hazard and vulnerability allows for the integration into a risk equation, resulting in five-level risk maps, with additional quantitative estimate of damage. The probability of occurrence of lahars is low, but impacts would be disastrous, with about 20,000 people and more directly exposed to it. Floods are much more recurrent, but affected areas are generally smaller. High-risk zones in Ibaguéare found in urban areas close to the main river with high social vulnerability. The methodology has proven to be a suitable tool to provide a first overview of spatial distribution of risk which is considered by local and regional authorities for disaster risk reduction. The harmonization of technical-engineering risk analysis and approaches from social sciences into common reference concepts should be further developed. Abstract The glacier-covered Nevado del Tolima in the Colombian Cordillera Central is an active volcano with potential lahars that might be more hazardous than those on Nevado del Ruiz. Furthermore, rainfall-triggered floods and landslides notoriously and severely affect the region. For effective disaster prevention, a risk analysis is of primary importance. We present here a risk analysis methodology that is based on the assessment of lahar and rainfall-related flood hazard scenarios and different aspects of vulnerability. The methodology is applied for populated centres in the Combeima valley and the regional capital Ibagué (*500,000 inhabitants). Lahar scenarios of 0.5, 1, 5, and 15 million m 3 volume are based on melting of 1, 2, 10, and 25 % of ice, firn and snow, respectively, due to volcanic activity and subsequent lahar formation. For flood modelling, design floods with a return period of 10 and 100 years were calculated. Vulnerability is assessed considering physical vulnerability, operationalized by market values of dwellin...

Risk estimation for future glacier lake outburst floods based on local land-use changes

“…A risk matrix more strongly weighted towards high risk classes (matrix a) can exert a dominant effect over socio-economic, while a more balanced risk matrix (b) quite obviously reduces the proportion of (very) high risk areas and gives higher weight to the effects of socio-economic development. Based on this analysis, a balanced risk matrix would probably be preferable; however, it should be underlined that the definition and choice of risk weighting is ultimately a task of policy and society and not science (Künzler et al, 2012).…”

A framework for the science contribution in climate adaptation: Experiences from science-policy processes in the Andes

“…Evans et al, 2009;Pierson et al, 1990;Terlien, 1997;Thouret et al, 1990;Vilimek et al, 2005). Studies that focus on policy relevant aspects such as hazard and risk mapping, or produce a basis for early warning systems are more rare but corresponding efforts have recently been strengthened (Huggel et al, 2010;Kü nzler et al, 2012;Schneider et al, 2014;Thouret et al, 2013).…”

Combining criteria for delineating lahar- and flash-flood-prone hazard and risk zones for the city of Arequipa, Peru

“…Ibagué in Colombia (Thouret and Laforge, 1994;Künzler et al, 2012) and Yogyakarta in Indonesia (Lavigne, 1999) are all located in vulnerable zones as urbanization encroaches the slopes of their nearby volcanoes. During a large eruption, pyroclastic flows, surges, and heavy tephra fall represent immediate and substantial hazards.…”

“…the characteristics of flows measured by parameters such as volume, height, velocity and density, modulated by the return period (Vallance, 2000). Vulnerability encompasses the foreseeable consequences of hazards on people and the assets to be affected by any given hazardous phenomenon (Künzler et al, 2012). Determining potential losses requires identifying the key factors which generate vulnerability.…”