Addressing the data guardian and geospatial scientist collaborator dilemma: how to share health records for spatial analysis while maintaining patient confidentiality

Abstract

BackgroundThe utility of being able to spatially analyze health care data in near-real time is a growing need. However, this potential is often limited by the level of in-house geospatial expertise. One solution is to form collaborative partnerships between the health and geoscience sectors. A challenge in achieving this is how to share data outside of a host institution’s protection protocols without violating patient confidentiality, and while still maintaining locational geographic integrity. Geomasking techniques have been previously championed as a solution, though these still largely remain an unavailable option to institutions with limited geospatial expertise. This paper elaborates on the design, implementation, and testing of a new geomasking tool Privy, which is designed to be a simple yet efficient mechanism for health practitioners to share health data with geospatial scientists while maintaining an acceptable level of confidentiality. The basic premise of Privy is to move the important coordinates to a different geography, perform the analysis, and then return the resulting hotspot outputs to the original landscape.ResultsWe show that by transporting coordinates through a combination of random translations and rotations, Privy is able to preserve location connectivity among spatial point data. Our experiments with typical analytical scenarios including spatial point pattern analysis and density analysis shows that, along with protecting spatial privacy, Privy maintains the spatial integrity of data which reduces information loss created due to data augmentation.ConclusionThe results from this study suggests that along with developing new mathematical techniques to augment geospatial health data for preserving confidentiality, simple yet efficient software solutions can be developed to enable collaborative research among custodians of medical and health data records and GIS experts. We have achieved this by developing Privy, a tool which is already being used in real-world situations to address the spatial confidentiality dilemma.

A distributed geospatial approach to describe community characteristics for multisite studies

“…Our distributed geospatial approach offers some important advantages compared to existing methods, including reduced exposure misclassification, maintaining participant confidentiality, and reducing the need for geospatial expertise at each study site [1]. One existing and alternative method to maintain subject confidentiality is the alteration of participants' geographic coordinates.…”

“…Maintaining patient privacy is a common challenge faced by researchers seeking to understand the relationship of place and health [1][2][3][4]. This issue can be especially problematic in multisite studies due to study protocols and confidentiality concerns that limit the sharing of geographic data.…”

On the Continuous Processing of Health Data in Edge-Fog-Cloud Computing by Using Micro/Nanoservice Composition

“…Integrity refers to the ability of the solutions to use checksums (e.g, SHA3 hashing or MD5) to ensure that data have not been modified in the transmission from one environment to another one [125]. Confidentiality was evaluated as the capacity of the solutions to preserve data privacy between processing stages and nodes [126], [127]. Finally, access controls were evaluated by considering techniques to establish cryptography-based controls to access the processing solutions [128].…”

Geographically Masking Addresses to Study COVID-19 Clusters

“…Privacy problems are inherent to health spatial data (Sherman & Fetters, 2007), and even more prominent when sciences tries to be reproducible (Ajayakumar, Curtis, & Curtis, 2019). And a recent study shows that visualisation with a high level of detail (e.g.…”