An Adaptive Hybrid Model for Determining Subjective Causal Relationships in Fuzzy System Dynamics Models for Analyzing Construction Risks

Abstract

Modeling risk management systems in construction projects is a complex process because of various internal and external factors and their interrelationships. Fuzzy system dynamics (FSD) have been commonly employed to model and analyze construction risk management systems. To run FSD simulation models, all hard (objective) and soft (subjective) causal relationships between variables must be quantified. However, a research gap exists regarding structured methods for constructing soft causal relationships in FSD models. This paper proposes an adaptive hybrid model consisting of fuzzy analytical hierarchy process, weighted principle of justifiable granularity, and fuzzy aggregation operators to determine crisp values of causality degree for soft (subjective) causal relationships in FSD modeling of construction risk analysis. The proposed model is implemented in analyzing construction risks of a windfarm project to illustrate its applicability. The proposed model generates two results: (1) optimized membership functions for linguistic terms representing the causality degree of soft relationships and (2) the crisp value for the causality degree of soft relationships. The contribution of study is to propose a structured model to improve efficiency and effectiveness of developing FSD quantitative modeling by addressing soft causal relationships between different variables in FSD models and considering multiple risk expertise of heterogeneous experts in construction risk assessment.

Dynamic risk assessment of storage tank using consequence modeling and fuzzy Bayesian network

“…Among the probabilistic methods for predicting the probability of accident and analyzing the accident are Fault tree method, Event tree method, Bow tie method and Bayesian network method [ 10 ]. Although, risk assessment methods have an important role in identifying risks and hazards, they have limitations made them difficult in analyzing the risk of complex and reciprocal systems [ 11 ]. The Fault tree method is widely used in the field of risk analysis, and error detection [ 12 ].…”

A novel stochastic fuzzy decision model for optimizing decision-making in the manufacturing industry

“…To address these limitations, there is a growing interest in developing decision models that integrate stochastic and fuzzy approaches (Solangi et al, 2019) (Biuki et al, 2020). The integration of stochastic elements allows for capturing the probabilistic nature of certain variables or events, while fuzzy logic provides a linguistic framework to handle subjective and imprecise information (Díaz-Curbelo et al, 2020) (Fateminia et al, 2021). This integration has the potential to offer a more comprehensive and robust decision-making framework that aligns with the complexities of the manufacturing industry (Prakash & Barua, 2016).…”