An application of input-output analysis to social enterprises: a case of the Czech Republic

Abstract

Purpose This paper aims to investigate the issue of performance measurement of social enterprises with main particular focus on economic performance approach reflecting local aspect, since the local aspect plays a significant role in social entrepreneurship concept. Thus, comparison of two instruments that consider local aspects: local multiplier 3 (LM3) and Input-Output analysis is examined. Input-Output analysis is empirically used to calculate social enterprises’ impact on the Czech economy and to confirm the assumption to be more suitable instrument for economic performance measurement of social enterprises in comparison to local multiplier 3 method. Design/methodology/approach The research adopted two-phase approach. At first a qualitative approach was used to compare the two selected instruments (LM3 and Input-Output analysis). Consequently, a quantitative research was applied to determine the impact of social enterprises’ activities on the economies of individual regions. The research was carried out on a sample of social enterprises (143 subjects) in the Czech Republic covering the year 2015. For this approach, Symmetric Input-Output tables and multipliers were calculated and revenue data from each observed social enterprise were used. Findings The findings of the research indicate effects of social enterprises’ activities on the economy in individual regions of the Czech Republic. The results clearly show that the impact of social enterprises on the Czech economy is not negligible. Calculated impacts differ in sectors as well as in regions. Besides, of these findings, the assumption that the Input-Output analysis is more appropriate instrument for economic performance measurement of social enterprises, especially in situation of a larger sample of social enterprises in different regions, in comparison to LM3 method, was confirmed. Research limitations/implications The limitations of this study is the dependence on the Symmetric Input-Output tables, which are usually published by local statistical offices and it takes some time to construct them. A more significant limitation and future research direction relates to the lack of generally accepted measurement framework in the sector of social enterprises and lack of the data, especially quantitative, in the Czech Republic. Practical implications The findings of the research represent a significant contribution to the process chain of understanding the role of social enterprises in (local) economy. The lack of proven impact of social enterprises to economy is considered as important limit of this sector development, not only from the perspective of investors and donors but also from the perspective of policymakers and even social enterprises themselves. The Input-Output analysis can be applied for any region of any country and can contribute to reduce scepticism about economic performance of social enterprises, thus to support putting social and environmental goals of social enterprises into practice. Social implications This research has been carried out on the so far largest identified sample of social enterprises in the Czech Republic and provides data for discourse among stakeholders about social enterprises’ impact; thus, it enables to understand their impact and make capable to enlarge their support network and development. Originality/value This research is a pioneering attempt to provide data about economic impact of social enterprises using Input-Output analysis in the Czech Republic. No previous research identifies such a large sample of Czech social enterprises and collects quantitative data about them, as well as considers Input-Output analysis as an option instead of LM3 method. The effort of this research has been to react on a research gap in studies related to the impact of social enterprises (reflecting local aspect). This paper could be understood as beneficial not only from the perspective of the Czech Republic but also worldwide.

Social business performance: is it possible to measure? Review and research agenda

“…This scenario reflects the challenge that social businesses have faced to measure their performance and the difficulty of standardizing this measurement across the business. Some studies have also presented mixed approaches to measuring performance in social businesses (Crucke & Decramer, 2016;Castellas et al, 2018;Son et al, 2018;Prochazkova & Noskova, 2020). For example, Castellas et al (2018) conducted interviews and surveys in data collection; performance information was collected quantitatively.…”

Addressing the COVID-19 challenges by SMEs in the hotel industry – a Czech sustainability message for emerging economies

“…Especially the role of employees and their (un)readiness to reconcile the brand co-creation with these challenges (Chung and Byrom, 2020) and to go even more vigorously for mutually supported CSR and total quality management in the hotel industry is pivotal (Jalilvand et al , 2018). As well the growing role of the impact of social enterprises, including those from the hotel industry, on the economy in the Czech Republic needs to be appreciated (Tausl Prochazkova and Noskova, 2020).…”

Measuring impacts of social enterprises: perspectives from Brazilians entrepreneurs and investors

“…Evaluation is a critical issue to such businesses, mainly because when identifying themselves as businesses that associate socio-environmental impact with profit, they are expected to testify their impact on society. According to Prochazkova and Noskova (2020), the absence of social impact-proof is a barrier to the development of the sector by investors, donors, policymakers and SE themselves. In this sense, evaluation supports, at the same time, the accountability of investments, organizational learning and legitimacy toward stakeholders (Lall, 2019; Bradford et al , 2020).…”