An Empirical Study on the Effects of Temporal Trends in Spatial Patterns on Animated Choropleth Maps

Abstract

Animated cartographic visualization incorporates the concept of geomedia presented in this Special Issue. The presented study aims to examine the effectiveness of spatial pattern and temporal trend recognition on animated choropleth maps. In a controlled laboratory experiment with participants and eye tracking, fifteen animated maps were used to show a different spatial patterns and temporal trends. The participants’ task was to correctly detect the patterns and trends on a choropleth map. The study results show that effective spatial pattern and temporal trend recognition on a choropleth map is related to participants’ visual behavior. Visual attention clustered in the central part of the choropleth map supports effective spatio-temporal relationship recognition. The larger the area covered by the fixation cluster, the higher the probability of correct temporal trend and spatial pattern recognition. However, animated choropleth maps are more suitable for presenting temporal trends than spatial patterns. Understanding the difficulty in the correct recognition of spatio-temporal relationships might be a reason for implementing techniques that support effective visual searches such as highlighting, cartographic redundancy, or interactive tools. For end-users, the presented study reveals the necessity of the application of a specific visual strategy. Focusing on the central part of the map is the most effective strategy for the recognition of spatio-temporal relationships.

Explanation and Analysis of Spatio-Temporal Correlations—Towards a Conceptual Approach of a Semantic Comparison Visualization in a Use Case of Carparks in Mainz, Germany

“…Current research mainly supports these challenges individually, claiming cartographic tools and techniques that support effective visual exploration and explanation. The research gaps relate mainly to temporal trends in spatial patterns [55] and the lack of appropriate tools for analyzing spatial relationships [56] in combined explanatory and analytical approaches. Statistical methods and results alone do not convey enough information for domain experts to make informed decisions [57].…”

Do navigation maps need a legend? Empirical assessment of the intuitiveness of point symbols on mobile maps

“…Empirical user studies can, among other things, investigate how users read map content and whether they do so accurately. Using em pirical research, cartographers can evaluate the design of various types of cartographic works: static maps (Havelková & Hanus, 2019), animated maps (Cybulski, 2022;Opach et al 2013) or atlases (Popelka et al, 2021). User studies help to empirically verify theoreti cal recommendations, e.g.…”

A Comparative Study of Methods for the Visualization of Probability Distributions of Geographical Data

“…To remove this limitation, HOMs use independent random samples similar to HOPs. More recently, Cybulski [45] presented a study of spatial pattern and temporal trend recognition on animated choropleth, highlighting the need of specific visual strategies.…”