Abstract. Understanding the effectiveness of long-term air pollution regulatory measures is important for control policy formulation. Efforts have been made
using chemical transport modelling and statistical approaches to evaluate the efficacy of the Clean Air Action Plan (CAAP; 2013–2017) and the Blue
Sky Protection Campaign (BSPC; 2018–2020) enacted in China. Changes in air quality due to reduction in emissions can be masked by meteorology,
making it highly challenging to reveal the real effects of control measures. A knowledge gap still existed with respect to how sources changed before
and after the CAAP and BSPC were implemented, respectively, particularly in coastal areas where anthropogenic emissions mixed with additional natural
sources (e.g. marine aerosol). This work applied a machine-learning-based meteorological normalization approach to decouple the meteorological
effects from air quality trend in a coastal city in northern China (Qingdao). Secondly, the relative changes in source contributions to ambient
PM2.5 with a ∼ 10-year observation interval (2011–2012, 2016, and 2019) were also investigated. We discovered that the largest
emission reduction section was likely from coal combustion as the meteorologically normalized SO2 dropped by
∼ 15.5 % yr−1, and the annual average dispersion-normalized SO42- decreased by ∼ 41.5 %. Change in the
meteorologically normalized NO2 was relatively stable (∼ 1.0 % yr−1), and NO3- changed inappreciably in
2016–2019 but was significantly higher than that prior to the CAAP. Crustal dust decreased remarkably after the CAAP began. Industrial emissions, for
example, steel-related smelting, decreased after 2016 due to the relocation of steel-making enterprises. Note that vehicle emissions were increased
in importance as opposed to the other primary sources. Similar to other megacities, Qingdao is also at risk of increased ozone pollution that in turn
facilitates secondary-particle formation in the future. The policy assessment approaches applied in this work also work for other places where air
quality management is highly in demand to reduce air pollution.