An Integrated Quantitative Safety Assessment Framework Based on the STPA and System Dynamics

Abstract

With the complexity of the socio-technical system, the requirement for safety analysis is growing. In actuality, system risk is frequently created by the interaction of numerous nonlinear-related components. It is essential to use safety assessment methods to identify critical risk factors in the system and evaluate the safety level of the system. An integrated safety assessment framework combining the system theoretic process analysis (STPA), the analytic network process (ANP) and system dynamics (SD) is suggested to analyze the safety level of socio-technical systems to achieve qualitative and quantitative safety evaluation. Our study constructs an STPA and SD integration framework to demonstrate the practical potential of combining STPA and SD approaches in terms of risk factors and causality. The framework uses the STPA method to define the static safety control structure of the system and analyzes the primary risk factors. The unsafe control actions (UCAs) from the STPA method are transformed into network layer elements of ANP. The ANP method is used to calculate the element weights, which are the impact coefficients between the system dynamics (SD) variables. The SD method is used to assess the safety level of the system. Finally, a specific coal mining system is used to demonstrate how the proposed hybrid framework works. The results indicated that the safety level of the system was low on days 38 and 120 of the simulation cycle (one quarter). Our work can overcome the limitations of conventional STPA quantitative analysis and simplify SD qualitative modeling to serve as a reference for complicated system safety/risk analysis work.

Resilience Capability of Indigenous People Affected by Small-Scale Gold Mining Activities: A Prevention Approach

“…In this literature case study, finding the center for the system dynamic model of ASGM explores input and output prevention scenarios by considering the ratio of the number of workers and the availability of river water as contributing variables that affect population and ASGM activities. At the level of inspection of the simulation analysis, the core observations are found to be similar to the simulation in [36]. This simulation shows that the BAU scale of the population graph continuously grows such that most of the concentration of community workers in Rarowatu Utara and Lantari Jaya has seen an increase in workforce starting in 2019.…”