Are Information Systems' Success and Failure Factors Related? An Exploratory Study

Abstract

Although the discipline of information systems (IS) development is well established, systems’ failure, abandonment, and dissatisfaction with functioning systems remain widespread. This has generated a considerable amount of literature investigating the factors seen to contribute to IS success and failure. However, little attention has been given to the possible relationships among the factors most influential in IS success and failure. Therefore, we examine the development of a successful system and compare the factors associated with the system’s success against the factors most reported in the literature as being associated with systems’ failure. Project management practices may be affected by knowing whether success and failure are two sides of one coin or different in nature. The results of our exploratory study showed that four of the six factors identified by the participants in our chosen system as being the most influential in the success of the system were directly related to the factors identified from the literature as being most associated with IS failure. Although more research needs to take place, these results would suggest a considerable relationship might exist between IS success and failure factors.

Emotional Intelligence and Project Success: The Roles of Transformational Leadership and Organizational Commitment

“…The performance of profitable organizations is influenced by management commitment (Kaplan & Norton, 2007). The commitment of top managers is an important success factor in the project planning phase (Fowler & Horan, 2007). Committed project managers are able to make a positive change in the project through monitoring the development and ensuring the project's available resources, which in turn can lead to successful project management (Pinto & Prescott, 1988).…”

Understanding perceived influencers on project outcomes and quantifying disciplinary similarities in academic literature

“…No print sources were gathered unless digitized. Because previous theories have suggested that studying the combination of success and failure is most conducive to understanding what predicts either (Belassi & Tukel, 1996; Fowler & Horan, 2007), sources discussing a project outcome (failure and/or success) were included. A holistic view was taken on the meaning of project failure and/or success, considering the entire project life cycle, and therefore including failures in operations such as accidents or systems failures.…”

The Impact of Information Technology Internal Controls on Firm Performance

“…One way to measure IT as a resource, is to examine IT's impact upon a firm's financial performance ratio's. Fowler and Horan (2007) state that information systems success can be measured by measures related to organizational performance. Return on assets (ROA) is a common financial ratio used to measure performance.…”