Artifacts associated with acoustic rhinometric assessment of infants and young children: a model study

Abstract

The present study was undertaken to determine in model studies whether currently available acoustic rhinometry instrumentation might be used to analyze the nasal cavity configuration of infants and children. A simple nasal cavity model was constructed using eight Lucite inserts that were placed between standard nosepieces provided by the manufacturer and a 35-cm-long polyvinyl chloride pipe closed at its distal end. To simulate the nasal valve, the inserts were 12 mm in length and had apertures ranging in diameter from 2 to 9 mm. A series of experiments was conducted to evaluate the accuracy with which the acoustic rhinometer measured the size of each insert aperture and the configuration of the model system distal to that aperture. Transmission losses caused errors in the area measurement of the insert aperture and the tube distal to the insert. When the insert aperture was < 6 mm in diameter (0.28 cm2), the aperture area was overestimated by > 10%, whereas the area of the distal tube was underestimated by > 10%. As a result of response lags, the acoustic rhinometer also failed to provide an accurate indication of insert length. Finally, oscillation artifacts caused estimates of the distal pipe area to fluctuate. These three systematic errors are described, and their potential impact on acoustic rhinometry in children is discussed.

Rinometria acústica: correlação anatômica dos dois primeiros entalhes encontrados no rinograma

“…Based on the results obtained in our study and in the study by Buenting et al 19 , we believe that the computer program used to obtain the rhinogram should inform the distances from notches calculated from initial point of notch and not only from the lowest point, as current programs do.…”

Improving the Reproducibility of Acoustic Rhinometry in the Assessment of Nasal Function

“…6 mm causes underestimation of deeper areas [4]. The accuracy of acoustic rhinometry diminishes with distance from the nose [5].…”

Avaliação da cavidade nasal e nasofaringe através da rinometria acústica antes e após adenoidectomia

“…Alegações vêm sendo feitas a respeito do potencial da rinometria acústica (RA) para a detecção e evolução de pacientes com hipertrofia adenoideana 4 embora muitos trabalhos evidenciam a baixa acurácia da RA em refletir a realidade anatômica da nasofaringe devido às próprias limitações da técnica 5,6 .…”