Assessing individual needs in Swedish elderly home care services: care managers’ argumentation in relation to the needs of migrant customers

Abstract

The aim of the article is to analyse and problematize care managers' argumentation of individual needs when assessing migrant customers within Swedish public elderly home care services. According to legislation, need for assistance should always be assessed individually. In recent decades of service decline, standardization of needs has been part of the distribution of elderly care services. Simultaneously, the stratum of older people has become more diverse, which means that a wider spectrum of needs is presented to the care managers. Ten interviews with care managers were analysed with a focus on their arguments regarding the care needs of elderly people with migrant backgrounds seeking assistance. The theoretical conceptions of the two perspectives of care and services were used to analyse the understanding of care managers' arguments. Our analysis shows that the service perspective with assistance and support that are standardized for Swedes is poorly suited to people born outside Sweden and socialized into other expectations of family and society. The meaning of individual needs was imprecise and contradictory when confronted with diverse cultural codes. When general standards were used in the arguments by referring to regulations and local guidelines, immigrants' individual needs were not prioritized. Our analysis suggests that the tension between national standards, local guidelines and individual needs has to be discussed further, where theoretical tools related to care and services may be useful in guiding care managers' professional arguments of individual needs and cultural sensitivity in the needs assessment.

The application and deployment of welfare technology in Swedish municipal care: a qualitative study of procurement practices among municipal actors

“…This study concedes that the estimation of costs and benefits is not value-neutral but rather tied to cultural understandings and negotiations of the needs of older adults or a persons at risk of disability, and the benefits that that welfare technology can provide [ 16 , 22 ]. In Sweden, as well as in other Nordic countries, care provision is influenced by a social norm of independency and autonomy [ 50 ]. Welfare technology fits well and advances the policy initiative of aging in place: older adults’ abilities to live independently in their homes for longer [ 23 ].…”

Äldre vuxnas perspektiv på välfärdsteknikens påverkan inom äldreomsorgen

“…Det innebär bland annat att välfärdsteknik förväntas att helt eller delvis kunna ersätta omsorgsarbetet som personalen utför, trots att omsorg innefattar ett individuellt ansvar för den andre för att kunna identifiera omsorgsmottagarens behov (jfr Noddings, 1984;Szebehely, 1995). För att skapa en god omsorg är det personliga mötet centralt, liksom att ha tid och kontinuitet (se exempelvis Andersson & Johansson, 2019;Johansson, 2016). Sammantaget innebär det att ge omsorgsinsatser till äldre i behov av hjälp och stöd, att kunna identifiera och tolka den andres behov samt att finna en individuell "lösning" till behovet.…”

Dokumentationens roll för klientskapande processer i äldreinriktat socialt arbete

“…Att identifikationsgrunder som kön, bakgrund och ålder är sammanflätade med den institutionella kategoriseringsprocessen kan tolkas i relation till andra studier som visar att biståndshandläggare betraktar ärenden med invandrade äldre -sent-i-livetinvandrade -som mer komplexa (Forssell, Torres & Olaison 2014, 2015Andersson & Johansson 2019) . En vidare tolkning kan även göras i relation till studier inom andra välfärdsområden, vilka föreslår att såväl stereotypifiering som moraliska föreställningar och bedömningar kan spela roll i ärendehanteringen (Hasenfeld 2009;Knechtel 2019) .…”