“…Nevertheless, although we are confident that contribution of reactive/labile phases from sedimentary sources is negligible, we cannot completely exclude this rare diagenesis process. In this regard, a recent study has shown that to a great extent, the most reactive/labile neodymium is released at the surface ocean, well above the thermocline 61 . In addition, an external source of new radiogenic ε Nd values during prolonged periods of time should have been recorded elsewhere, but there are no evidences for it in the published records of authigenic or lithogenic neodymium [39][40][41]50,62 .…”