Assessing Species Boundaries Using Multilocus Species Delimitation in a Morphologically Conserved Group of Neotropical Freshwater Fishes, the Poecilia sphenops Species Complex (Poeciliidae)

Abstract

Accurately delimiting species is fundamentally important for understanding species diversity and distributions and devising effective strategies to conserve biodiversity. However, species delimitation is problematic in many taxa, including ‘non-adaptive radiations’ containing morphologically cryptic lineages. Fortunately, coalescent-based species delimitation methods hold promise for objectively estimating species limits in such radiations, using multilocus genetic data. Using coalescent-based approaches, we delimit species and infer evolutionary relationships in a morphologically conserved group of Central American freshwater fishes, the Poecilia sphenops species complex. Phylogenetic analyses of multiple genetic markers (sequences of two mitochondrial DNA genes and five nuclear loci) from 10/15 species and genetic lineages recognized in the group support the P. sphenops species complex as monophyletic with respect to outgroups, with eight mitochondrial ‘major-lineages’ diverged by ≥2% pairwise genetic distances. From general mixed Yule-coalescent models, we discovered (conservatively) 10 species within our concatenated mitochondrial DNA dataset, 9 of which were strongly supported by subsequent multilocus Bayesian species delimitation and species tree analyses. Results suggested species-level diversity is underestimated or overestimated by at least ~15% in different lineages in the complex. Nonparametric statistics and coalescent simulations indicate genealogical discordance among our gene tree results has mainly derived from interspecific hybridization in the nuclear genome. However, mitochondrial DNA show little evidence for introgression, and our species delimitation results appear robust to effects of this process. Overall, our findings support the utility of combining multiple lines of genetic evidence and broad phylogeographical sampling to discover and validate species using coalescent-based methods. Our study also highlights the importance of testing for hybridization versus incomplete lineage sorting, which aids inference of not only species limits but also evolutionary processes influencing genetic diversity.

In love and war: The morphometric and phylogenetic basis of ornamentation, and the evolution of male display behavior, in the livebearer genus Poecilia

“…Mollienesia , in particular, is the most species‐rich subgenus of Poecilia as well as the one with the most recent divergences between species (Bagley et al. ; Ho et al. ; Palacios et al.…”

Microbial mats as shelter microhabitat for amphipods in an intermittent karstic spring

“…nov. (Strunecky et al, 2013). Still, the taxonomic uncertainty of identifying morphospecies could produce spurious phylogenetic inferences (Bagley et al, 2015), specially when RNA sequencing of samples classified as P. autumnale indicates the presence of several different genotypes (Strunecky et al, 2013). Furthermore, when compared with the results of a partial 16S rRNA phylogeny, ecotype preferences used to separate M. vaginatus from P. autumnale proved fairly inaccurate.…”

The imperiled fish fauna in the Nicaragua Canal zone

“…According to a recent phylogeny on fishes of the genus Poecilia in Central America (Bagley et al. ), these genetic clusters refer to P. mexicana clade 8a, P. mexicana clade 8m, and P . sp.…”

“…, Supporting Information) according to a recent phylogeny (Bagley et al. ). We aligned cytb sequences and built maximum likelihood phylogenetic trees with SeaView version 4 (Gouy et al.…”

“…Bagley et al. () detected a third genetic cluster, referred to as Poecilia sp. Tipitapa, that falls outside the P. shenops and P. mexicana species complexes.…”