Assessing the performance of a supply chain for organic vegetables from a smallholder perspective

Abstract

Purpose -The purpose of this paper is to identify factors that constrain marketing choices available to smallholders, limiting the chain's robustness from their perspective. Design/methodology/approach -This paper draws on transaction cost economics to develop a model explaining dyadic relationships between smallholders and their buyers. The model was used to analyse a case study of the supply chain for organic fresh vegetables in Kathmandu, Nepal. Findings -This chain is characterised mainly by relational contracting between smallholders and their buyers. There was also evidence of vertical integration by some buyers, and of growers selling on informal markets. However, there was no evidence of spot market trading or of conventional contracting. These outcomes were attributed primarily to the absence effective standards and legal systems. Despite this, the chain offered smallholders a range of dyads with different risk-reward trade-offs. Research limitations/implications -This paper is based on the findings of a case study. While the results can be generalised to theory, they cannot be generalised to other supply chains. Originality/value -This study considers supply-chain performance from the perspective of smallholders. The model proposed for the study extends the traditional vertical coordination continuum to incorporate missing dyads and informal markets.

Value chain performance improvement for sustainable mango industry development in Pakistan

“…Therefore agri-food industries should make adequate contributions to the welfare of associated communities. However, it is argued that the transformation process has given rise to several social challenges, under the influences of which social contributions from agri-food industries have become inadequate (Bhattarai et al 2013). These challenges include unemployment, low wages, child labour, gender imbalance, worker safety and welfare.…”

“…According to Bhattarai et al (2013), inadequate information sharing provides opportunities for informed actors in the chain to exploit others. Grimm et al (2014) went further, to state that this had become a critical barrier to the development of sustainable value chains.…”

Malt barley commercialization through contract farming scheme: A systematic review of experiences and prospects in Ethiopia

“…Transaction costs are influenced by the characteristics of the transaction, product and environment within which transactions occur (Bhattarai et al, 2013). These are asset specificity, frequency and uncertainty as the three most important characteristics of transactions that alter the cost of engaging in an exchange.…”

“…The seasonality and perishability of agricultural products also increases the complexity of transacting, particularly when markets require specific quality standards and credence attributes in products. Complexity increases transaction costs by increasing the uncertainty of supply, by increasing information and monitoring costs, by increasing the need for assets that have little value in alternative uses, and by increasing the cost of renegotiating incomplete contracts ex post (Bhattarai et al, 2013).…”

Enhancing Competitiveness Business Strategy of Organic Vegetables Using Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP)

“…This chain is characterised mainly by relational contracting between smallholders and their buyers. There was also evidence of vertical integration by some buyers, and of growers selling on informal markets (Bhattarai et al, 2013). Lohmann and Foster (2006) compare niche and mainstream of marketing strategies in UK and Germany found that considers the present situation and future challenges of organic food, In the UK, there is potential for the expansion of small-scale, decentralized marketing outlets, while in Germany greater involvement by supermarkets appears to be appropriate.…”