Assessing the state of lean and six sigma practices in healthcare in Mexico

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this study is to assess the state at which lean and six sigma (LSS) are used as a management system to improve the national health system national health system of Mexico. Design/methodology/approach Cross-sectional survey-research. The survey was administered at 30 different hospitals across six states in Mexico. These were selected using convenience sampling and participants (N = 258) were selected through random/snowball sampling procedures, including from top managers down to front-line staff. Findings Only 16 per cent of respondents reported participation in LSS projects. Still, these implementations are limited to using isolated tools, mainly 5s, failure mode and effects analysis (FMEA) and Fishbone diagram, with the lack of training/knowledge and financial resources as the top disabling factors. Overall, LSS has not become systematic in daily management and operations. Research limitations/implications The sampling procedure was by convenience; however, every attempt was made to ensure a lack of bias in the individual responses. If still there was a bias, it is conjectured that this would likely be in overestimating the penetration of LSS. Practical implications The penetration of LSS management practices into the Mexican health system is in its infancy, and the sustainability of current projects is jeopardized given the lack of systematic integration. Hence, LSS should be better spread and communicated across healthcare organizations in Mexico. Originality/value This is the first research work that evaluates the use of LSS management practices in a Latin American country, and the first journal paper that focuses on LSS in healthcare in Mexico.

Assessing the Impact of Lean Healthcare on Inpatient Care: A Systematic Review

“…We found 25 out of 39 studies combining lean with tools and principles of the six sigma methodology, suggesting that such integration offers a more robust approach to improving speed, quality and costs, increasing customer satisfaction, and maximizing shareholder value [ 153 , 154 ]. While lean focuses on reducing waste and NVA activities, six sigma focuses on reducing process variation by following the DMAIC approach (Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve and Control) and by using statistical tools.…”

A Conceptual Model That Identifies Mathematical Models and Lean Techniques for Problem-Solving at the Different Decision-Making Levels of Service Companies

“…Regarding the production of articles on health service topics, we have considered the following literature reviews, conducted for Mexico by Peimbert-García et al (Peimbert-García et al, 2019) and a more general by Vaishnavi, V., & Suresh, M. (Vaishnavi & Suresh, 2020), in which a panorama is presented for the application of Lean Six Sigma (LSS) in health care organizations. Peimbert-García, et al (Peimbert-García et al, 2019) presents an article that provides an overview of the penetration of LSS management practices in the Mexican health care system, through a survey of 30 hospitals in six states of the Republic, to which N = 258 responded, including senior management and frontline staff. It was found that the penetration of LSS initiatives in Mexico's health care system is still in its infancy since only 16% of those surveyed had participated in an LSS initiative, and these were used equally in public and private hospitals.…”

Utilization of Lean & Six Sigma quality initiatives in Indian healthcare sector

“…The results showed that there were significant differences between the staff of the public hospitals and private hospitals on Lean and Six Sigma initiatives. Peimbert-Garcia et al [ 6 ] assessed the status of Lean & Six Sigma practices in healthcare in Mexico. They observed that only 16% of the respondents had implemented the Lean & Six Sigma projects.…”