Belongingness and its implications for undergraduate health professions education: a scoping review

Abstract

Belongingness is well recognised within higher education to have an important influence on the performance and well-being of learners. There appears to be little awareness of its importance in undergraduate health professions education. To identify how belongingness has been defined and measured, its impact on the performance and well-being of learners, and how it can be fostered in educational settings. A scoping review to map the published research in the wider higher education literature (including undergraduate health professions education). PubMed and ERIC were used. Only peer-reviewed articles in the English Language between 1996 and 2016 were included. Fifty-one relevant articles were identified with 16 related to nurse clinical education. No studies were found in undergraduate medical education or in primary care educational settings. Common features were identified within the several definitions of belongingness. A thematic analysis of articles revealed that belongingness has an important role in student motivation and learning identity formation and in facilitating positive mental health. The scoping review highlighted the importance of belongingness in higher and undergraduate health professions education, with implications for future practice and policy. Further research is recommended. There are important implications for curriculum development and delivery, including clinical placements; within secondary and primary care health professional education.

‘You’ve got mail!': Clinical and practical skills teaching re-imagined during COVID-19

“…Connection is important for maintaining self-esteem, identity development, wellbeing and sense of belonging. [10][11][12][13] Both students and tutors faced technological challenges when WiFi connections were weak and camera angles were unsuitable. Tutors faced further challenges; becoming fluent with the digital platform and attempting to maximise the pedagogical experience for students while avoiding technical errors was time consuming.…”

The F3 phenomenon: Early‐career training breaks in medical training. A scoping review

“…Levac et al’s 15 paper ‘Scoping studies: advancing the methodology’, which builds upon Arksey and O’Malley's original scoping review framework, 65 recommends that two reviewers should review articles for inclusion within the ‘Study selection’ phase. Although there is no specific guidance on an optimal number of reviewers for the ‘Charting the data’ phase, other published scoping reviews appear to favour two authors 66‐68 . Furthermore, given that systematic reviews conform to much stricter methodological requirements to achieve their superior evidence status and also recommend two independent reviewers, 69 we consider our review in this context methodology rigorous.…”

Myocarditis Post mRNA COVID-19 Vaccine- To Fear or Not to Fear?

“…This is because educational theories accept that learning is a social event and that people do not learn in isolation. Socialization plays an important role in students learning and professional identity formation and belongingness is found to be a key factor that develops this socialization [3]. Individual perception of belonging to an institution and the learning environment was found to be a factor in commitment and learning success.…”