Bidirectionality, mediation, and moderation of metaphorical effects: The embodiment of social suspicion and fishy smells.

Abstract

Metaphorical effects are commonly assumed to be unidirectional, running from concrete to abstract domains but not vice versa. Noting that metaphorical effects are often found to be bidirectional, we explore how they may be mediated and moderated according to the principles of knowledge accessibility and applicability. Using the example of "something smells fishy" (a metaphorical expression of social suspicion), 7 experiments tested for the behavioral effects of fishy smells on social suspicion among English speakers, the reversed effects of suspicion on smell labeling and detection, and the underlying mechanism. Incidental exposure to fishy smells induced suspicion and undermined cooperation in trust-based economic exchanges in a trust game (Study 1) and a public goods game (Study 2). Socially induced suspicion enhanced the correct labeling of fishy smells, but not other smells (Studies 3a-3c), an effect that could be mediated by the accessibility and moderated by the applicability of metaphorically associated concepts (Studies 4-6). Suspicion also heightened detection sensitivity to low concentrations of fishy smells (Study 7). Bidirectionality, mediation, and moderation of metaphorical effects have important theoretical implications for integrating known wisdom from social cognition with new insights into the embodied and metaphorical nature of human thinking. These findings also highlight the need for exploring the cultural variability and origin of metaphorical knowledge.

Toward a Radically Embodied Neuroscience of Attachment and Relationships?

“…Specifically, IJzerman and Koole (2011) explained that this aspect of their theory was not true for warmth related effects (see also Lee and Schwarz, 2012; for skepticism of this view), as they discuss findings showing that relationship warmth has an effect on the perception of ambient temperature (for original studies and replications, see Zhong and Leonardelli, 2008;IJzerman and Semin, 2010;Szymkow et al, 2013;IJzerman et al, 2015a; for a notable non-replication, see Ebersole et al, 2015). As an alternative to Lakoff and Johnson's model, IJzerman and Koole (2011) identified Barsalou's (1999, 2008 perceptual symbol systems (PSSs) as a rival candidate for attachment-related processes regarding underlying psychological processes in which concepts are built in perceptual systems through simulations relying on perceptual elements.…”

The scope and consequences of metaphoric thinking: Using individual differences in metaphor usage to understand how metaphor functions.

“…These are cases in which people seem to be victims of their tendencies to think metaphorically, for example in the form of basing potentially important decisions about trust and distrust on whether there are fishy smells in the environment (Lee & Schwarz, 2012).…”

An Embodiment Perspective on Protection Motivation Theory: The Impact of Incidental Weight Sensations on Threat-Appraisal, Coping-Appraisal, and Protection Motivation

“…However, previous research has neglected the potential impact of basal bodily sensations on cognitions determining health motivation. This is surprising as the theory of embodied cognition suggests a strong bidirectional relationship between bodily experiences and higher cognitive processes (Lee & Schwarz, 2012). Here, I will demonstrate that this concept is of particular importance for healthy behaviour.…”