Big data in sleep medicine: prospects and pitfalls in phenotyping

Abstract

Clinical polysomnography (PSG) databases are a rich resource in the era of “big data” analytics. We explore the uses and potential pitfalls of clinical data mining of PSG using statistical principles and analysis of clinical data from our sleep center. We performed retrospective analysis of self-reported and objective PSG data from adults who underwent overnight PSG (diagnostic tests, n=1835). Self-reported symptoms overlapped markedly between the two most common categories, insomnia and sleep apnea, with the majority reporting symptoms of both disorders. Standard clinical metrics routinely reported on objective data were analyzed for basic properties (missing values, distributions), pairwise correlations, and descriptive phenotyping. Of 41 continuous variables, including clinical and PSG derived, none passed testing for normality. Objective findings of sleep apnea and periodic limb movements were common, with 51% having an apnea–hypopnea index (AHI) >5 per hour and 25% having a leg movement index >15 per hour. Different visualization methods are shown for common variables to explore population distributions. Phenotyping methods based on clinical databases are discussed for sleep architecture, sleep apnea, and insomnia. Inferential pitfalls are discussed using the current dataset and case examples from the literature. The increasing availability of clinical databases for large-scale analytics holds important promise in sleep medicine, especially as it becomes increasingly important to demonstrate the utility of clinical testing methods in management of sleep disorders. Awareness of the strengths, as well as caution regarding the limitations, will maximize the productive use of big data analytics in sleep medicine.

SleepOMICS: How Big Data Can Revolutionize Sleep Science

“…“Real life” and real-time behavioral (sensor-based), molecular, digital/computational, and epidemiological big data represent the sources of an impressive wealth of information that can be exploited in order to advance the field of sleep research [70,71,72].…”

Heart rate phenotypes and clinical correlates in a large cohort of adults without sleep apnea

“… 47 , 48 On the other hand, resource shifts toward at-home diagnostics, with limited-channel devices designed for uncomplicated OSA detection, 49 are unlikely to directly support improved phenotyping efforts. Efforts to improve in-laboratory PSG-based phenotyping 43 , 50 , 51 could improve risk stratification and guide care decisions. The information contained in cardiac channels is well suited for implementation via both in-laboratory and at-home diagnostics, as cardiac physiology (either HR or ECG) is present in both clinical recording contexts.…”

A Systematic Review of Literature on Automated Sleep Scoring

“…Typically one wants to extract significant patterns, trends, interactions, and associations. Three V's are used to characterize many big data situations: Velocity (Data Acquisition speed), Volume (Amount of Data), and Variety (Number of sources to create big data sets) [155], [156].…”

“…Variation across recording and scoring technologists may contribute heterogeneity despite quality efforts required in accredited laboratories. Centralized scoring common to large clinical trials may not be practical for clinical databases'' [155].…”