Biomedical Data Sharing and Reuse: Attitudes and Practices of Clinical and Scientific Research Staff

Abstract

BackgroundSignificant efforts are underway within the biomedical research community to encourage sharing and reuse of research data in order to enhance research reproducibility and enable scientific discovery. While some technological challenges do exist, many of the barriers to sharing and reuse are social in nature, arising from researchers’ concerns about and attitudes toward sharing their data. In addition, clinical and basic science researchers face their own unique sets of challenges to sharing data within their communities. This study investigates these differences in experiences with and perceptions about sharing data, as well as barriers to sharing among clinical and basic science researchers.MethodsClinical and basic science researchers in the Intramural Research Program at the National Institutes of Health were surveyed about their attitudes toward and experiences with sharing and reusing research data. Of 190 respondents to the survey, the 135 respondents who identified themselves as clinical or basic science researchers were included in this analysis. Odds ratio and Fisher’s exact tests were the primary methods to examine potential relationships between variables. Worst-case scenario sensitivity tests were conducted when necessary.Results and DiscussionWhile most respondents considered data sharing and reuse important to their work, they generally rated their expertise as low. Sharing data directly with other researchers was common, but most respondents did not have experience with uploading data to a repository. A number of significant differences exist between the attitudes and practices of clinical and basic science researchers, including their motivations for sharing, their reasons for not sharing, and the amount of work required to prepare their data.ConclusionsEven within the scope of biomedical research, addressing the unique concerns of diverse research communities is important to encouraging researchers to share and reuse data. Efforts at promoting data sharing and reuse should be aimed at solving not only technological problems, but also addressing researchers’ concerns about sharing their data. Given the varied practices of individual researchers and research communities, standardizing data practices like data citation and repository upload could make sharing and reuse easier.

Research data management in the age of big data: Roles and opportunities for librarians

“…The vast amount of data already available in these repositories demonstrates that many researchers are open to sharing their data, though research has demonstrated that researchers' willingness to share their data may vary widely depending on a variety of factors, including their field of research, years of experience in the field, and type of funding [13,31,34]. However, regardless of whether a researcher feels open to sharing their data or not, chances are good that most researchers will soon be required to do so.…”

Exploring barriers and solutions in advancing cross-centre population data science

“…There is an identified need for a framework that builds familiarity, trust, mutual purpose and dependency across a data sharing community of practice that allows risks to be understood and mitigated [19]. Whilst technical challenges are not trivial and solutions are essential, a key message in the literature is that cultural factors are likely to be harder to solve [18,21].…”

Collaborating to Increase the Evidence Base in Library and Information Practice

“…Table 2 Reasons for Not Sharing Data from NIH Study (Federer et al, 2015) Digital research data storage amounts and locations from Emory survey (Akers & Doty, 2013).…”