Building a Social Contract? Understanding Tax Morale in Nigeria

Abstract

An important part of every country's development process is the building of a social contract in which citizens pay tax and, in turn, receive public goods and services. Evidence suggests that this is associated with the establishment of a norm of tax payment and a belief that non-payment is wrong. We exploit a new, nationally representative, dataset to explore which factors are associated with higher tax morale in Nigeria. We find that a perception of higher penalties and greater difficulty avoiding taxes are both associated with higher tax morale. Tax morale is also higher the more people believe that other Nigerians pay taxes, the less frequently they have to pay bribes and the greater the trust they have in tax officials. However, we also find that Nigerians who believe that tax officials discriminate in their treatment of different ethnic, religious and gender groups have higher, not lower, tax morale. And we find no relationship between service delivery and measures of tax morale based on the respondent's own behaviour, in contrast to the positive association found in the literature using broader measures of tax morale. This suggests that building a social contract based on taxation may be harder than previously thought.

Protest Matters: The Effects of Protests on Economic Redistribution

“…To test these hypotheses, we use data on public service provision perceptions and tax morale from a new 2018 survey of 16, 228 randomly sampled adult respondents in Nigeria (McCulloch, Moerenhout, and Yang, 2020). Summary statistics are provided in Table A10.…”

Taxation in Namibia: an everyday political practice without deliberation and influence

“…While services and government performance are important, the way the relationship with the state is conceived, emotionally embedded and practiced may give taxes very different roles and functions in the eyes of the citizen (Ahmed 2004; Körling 2011; Söderström 2015: 82–113, 158–65; McCulloch et al . 2021: 237). How taxes are talked and thought about, taps into the deeper question of how the relationship between the state and the citizen is envisioned, and how the state and the social contract are continually reproduced; ultimately providing us with a deeper understanding of the citizen taxpayer.…”

Property Tax and Sustainable Development in Ekiti State: Citizens’ Perspective

“…The building of a social contract, in which citizens pay tax and, in turn, enjoy the benefit of the tax paid through the provision of public goods and services by the government, represents an integral part of a nation's sustainable development (Mcculloch, Moerenhout, and Yang, 2020;Tengs, 2020). The establishment of a new tax policy, in order to ensure the availability of adequate fund, for the pursuit of inclusive sustainable development cannot be overemphasized, especially in developing nations such as Nigeria and, by extension, Ekiti State.…”