Building-up resilience and being effective leaders in the workplace: a systematic review and synthesis model

Abstract

PurposePsychological resilience, defined here as the capacity to bounce back from adversity and failure, has been studied in various leadership contexts. However, the literature demonstrates less consensus concerning how psychological resilience manifests in, and interacts within, the leadership role and, equally, the focus on resilience development is underdeveloped. This paper addresses these issues by focusing on the interactions between psychological resilience and leadership and presents practical development strategies.Design/methodology/approachA systematic review employing 46 empirical studies followed a thematic synthesis within an associated model encapsulated as building-up resilience and being effective.FindingsFirst, resilience is identified as essential and can benefit individuals and organizations' work outcomes across leadership contexts, including work performance, job engagement, well-being, and enhanced leadership capability. Secondly, leaders may build up their resilience by obtaining coping skills and improved attitudes toward challenges. Resilient attitudes, which are presented as paradoxical perspectives towards challenges, may help leaders adapt to challenges and adversities leading to beneficial outcomes.Research limitations/implicationsEven though this study provides a deeper understanding of the essential function of psychological resilience in leadership, the findings are limited to the workplace contexts investigated, e.g. exploring small sample sizes (13,019) or country contexts (22). Future research could expand the rhetoric around interactions between psychological resilience and leadership. Furthermore, the underlining mechanism between the paradoxical perspective and resilient attitudes is still largely unclear. Thus, more research is needed to disclose the interaction of paradoxical perceptions and leadership resilience. Further research can investigate how resilient attitudes demonstrate in actions in dealing with challenges and adversities.Practical implicationsThe authors further an argument that leaders may enhance their resilience through embracing a paradoxical perspective towards challenges (resilient attitude), e.g. being adaptive to adversities, and the attitude of learning from failures. These enhanced resilient attitudes could help leaders deeper understand and examine their reality and persist under high pressures and develop an innate ability to utilise resources more effectively to help them survive and thrive in challenging circumstances, instead of becoming overwhelmed by the burden of complexity or giving up. This will offer a practical contribution to resilience development.Social implicationsImportantly, this study found that resilience is an essential leadership trait and can benefit individuals and organizations' work outcomes across leadership contexts. These positive effects of resilience may encourage organizations or society to promote psychological resilience, including a resilient attitude, to deal with adversities and uncertainties.Originality/valueFun...

Growth-oriented management and employee outcomes: employee resilience as a mechanism for growth

“…GOM provides employees with the autonomy (and support) to engage in flexible decision making, situational awareness, and creative problem solving, all of which aid adaptation (Tonkin et al, 2018). Furthermore, growth-oriented managers understand the unique needs and personalities of individual employees, and as a result, are adept at capably and appropriately recognizing and supporting them flexibly, in ways that work for them as individuals, and which may also change over time (Yu et al, 2022;Zhang et al, 2015). This flexible approach to job and career management allows employees to see that their behaviors, and the associated standards for performance, are not fixed, and they are supported to adapt their behaviors as demands on work change (N€ aswall et al, 2019).…”

“…Embedded in GOM is an ability to build shared coherence by linking individual goals to the group and developing compatible role expectations both at the individual and collaborative levels (Franken, 2019). These behaviors build the confidence for employees to effectively develop and leverage networks themselves, facilitating collective learning and the productive exchange of knowledge and ideas (Yu et al, 2022;Nguyen et al, 2016). This is essential for the maintenance of resilience (and thus the development of growth), since the open collaboration that arises through network leveraging is likely to bolster other resilient behaviors related to learning and adapting, as it allows for the adaptive use of "collective competencies to resolve shared issues and challenges" (Franken et al, 2019, p. 19).…”

“…, 2018). Furthermore, growth-oriented managers understand the unique needs and personalities of individual employees, and as a result, are adept at capably and appropriately recognizing and supporting them flexibly, in ways that work for them as individuals, and which may also change over time (Yu et al. , 2022; Zhang et al.…”

“…Embedded in GOM is an ability to build shared coherence by linking individual goals to the group and developing compatible role expectations both at the individual and collaborative levels (Franken, 2019). These behaviors build the confidence for employees to effectively develop and leverage networks themselves, facilitating collective learning and the productive exchange of knowledge and ideas (Yu et al. , 2022; Nguyen et al.…”

Professionalizing all-volunteer nonprofit organizations: an intervention study based on the competing values framework and self-determination theory

“…All organizations -whether for-profit, governmental or nonprofit-are operating within a rapidly changing environment, with specific aspirations of numerous stakeholders (Balduck et al, 2015;Yu et al, 2022). To anticipate environmental changes, these organizations need to Nonprofit organizations…”