Can electronic assessment tools improve the process of shared decision-making? A systematic review

Abstract

Background: Patient involvement in decision-making plays a prominent role in improving the quality of healthcare. Despite this, shared decision-making is not routinely implemented. However, electronic assessment tools that capture patients’ history, symptoms, opinions and values prior to their medical appointment are used by healthcare professionals during patient consultations to facilitate shared decision-making. Objective: To assess the effectiveness of electronic assessment tools to improve the shared decision-making process. Method: A systematic review was conducted following PRISMA guidelines. Published literature was searched on MEDLINE, EMBASE and PsycINFO to identify potentially relevant studies. Data were extracted and analysed narratively. Results: Seventeen articles, representing 4004 participants, were included in this review. The main findings were significant improvement in patient–provider communication and provider management of patient condition in the intervention group compared to the control group. In contrast, patient–provider satisfaction and time efficiency were assessed by relatively few included studies, and the effects of these outcomes were inconclusive. Conclusion: This review found that communication and healthcare professional’s management of a patient’s condition improves because of the use of electronic questionnaires. This is encouraging because the process of shared decision-making is reliant on high-quality communication between healthcare professionals and patients. Implications: We found that this intervention is especially important for people with chronic diseases, as they need to establish a long-term relationship with their healthcare provider and agree to a treatment plan that aligns with their values. More rigorous research with validated instruments is required.

Improving the Process of Shared Decision-Making by Integrating Online Structured Information and Self-Assessment Tools

“…An increasing number of digital consumer and patient health tools are being developed for use on electronic devices such as computers and smartphones as standalone software or websites. Online resources to facilitate SDM have been advocated [4]; however, concerns have been raised over the effectiveness of electronic assessment tools at improving the shared decision-making process [5]. Various techniques have been designed to help patients obtain the information they need to enable them to play an active role in their care under a more equitable partnership.…”

A novel framework for bringing smart big data to proactive decision making in healthcare

“…Thus, big data after reconstruction using smart big data can achieve wide knowledge-based and self-evolving proactive decision-making models. [10][11][12] To sum up, our original intention of proposing a smart big data driven model is suitable for healthcare.…”

Community-based participatory research with police: Development of a tech-enhanced structured suicide risk assessment and communication smartphone application.

“…App-based assessment has long been considered commonplace in the medical and nursing literature (e.g., Flynn et al, 2018). Electronic versions of assessments that auto-populate electronic medical records, functionally equivalent to app-based assessments, have seen wide adoption and have been demonstrated to improve patients’ health care (e.g., Wickramasekera et al, 2020).…”