Cell-state transitions and frequency-dependent interactions among subpopulations together explain the dynamics of spontaneous epithelial-mesenchymal heterogeneity in breast cancer

Abstract

Individual cells in a tumour can be distributed among Epithelial (E) and Mesenchymal (M) cell-states, as characterised by the levels of canonical E and M markers. Even after E and M (E-M) subpopulations are isolated and then cultured independently, E-M heterogeneity can re-equilibrate in each population over time, sometimes regaining the initial distribution of the parental cell population. However, it remains unclear which population-level processes give rise to the dynamical changes in E-M heterogeneity observed experimentally, including 1) differential growth, 2) cell-state switching, and 3) frequency-dependent growth or state-transition rates. Here, we analyse the necessity of these three processes in explaining the dynamics of E-M population distributions as observed in PMC42-LA and HCC38 breast cancer cells. We find that growth differences among E and M subpopulations, with and without any frequency-dependent interactions (cooperation or suppression) among E-M sub-populations, are insufficient to explain the observed population dynamics. This insufficiency is ameliorated by including cell-state transitions, albeit at slow rates, in explaining both PMC42-LA and HCC38 cells data. Further, our models predict that treatment of HCC38 cells with TGFβ signalling and JAK2/3 inhibitors could significantly enhance the transition rates from M state to E state, but does not prevent transitions from E to M. Finally, we devise a selection criterion to identify the next most informative time points for which future experimental data can optimally improve the identifiability of our estimated best fit model parameters. Overall, our study identifies the necessary population-level processes shaping the dynamics of E-M heterogeneity in breast cancer cells.