Citizens’ Opinions About Basic Income Proposals Compared – A Conjoint Analysis of Finland and Switzerland

Abstract

The basic income (BI) scheme is a fundamental reform of the welfare state that has recently gained widespread attention. Proposals for different variants of BI schemes have emerged to account for varying political and societal goals. This study investigates what citizens think about the idea of a BI, and to what extent citizens’ perceptions depend on the exact design of such a scheme and the context in which this policy is embedded. Empirically, we rely on conjoint experiments conducted in Finland and Switzerland – the two countries in which the introduction of a BI scheme has recently been discussed most intensely. We find that the level of public support for BI is higher in Finland than it is in Switzerland. Moreover, despite the contrasting designs of the BI proposals in the two countries, both Finnish and Swiss citizens tend to favor more generous schemes restricting non-nationals’ access to the provision.

Snowballing or wilting? What affects public support for varying models of basic income?

“…These findings complement existing research on the multi-dimensionality of basic income, where an increase in taxes (be it Value Added Tax, personal income taxes, or transaction taxes) reduces support relative to cutting back government expenses, although the effect is not significant (Stadelmann-Steffen & Dermont, 2019). Interestingly, our findings here may explain why the difference in support between taxes and cuts is not significant: no funding mechanism is popular at all.…”

Automation and the future of the welfare state: basic income as a response to technological change?

“…1 A candidate in the 2020 US Democratic Primaries (Andrew Yang) even ran his platform predominantly on this issue. In Switzerland, a popular initiative calling for a universal basic income amongst other with those arguments was rejected in 2016, and Finland implemented a large-scale experiment in 2016/2017 to test the consequences of such a scheme (Stadelmann-Steffen and Dermont 2020). Finally, the Five Star Movement government in Italy launched a 'citizens' income' in 2019.…”

The Politics of Renewable Energy Production in a Federal Context: The Deployment of Small Hydropower in the Swiss Cantons

“…We used the mean of the standardized values. Finally, we used survey data—the percentage of respondents who agree that small-scale hydropower should play a larger role in Switzerland’s future energy mix—to measure the sociopolitical acceptance that small-scale hydropower enjoys in each canton (Stadelmann-Steffen & Dermont, 2016).…”