Combined Fishing and Climate Forcing in the Southern Benguela Upwelling Ecosystem: An End-to-End Modelling Approach Reveals Dampened Effects

Abstract

The effects of climate and fishing on marine ecosystems have usually been studied separately, but their interactions make ecosystem dynamics difficult to understand and predict. Of particular interest to management, the potential synergism or antagonism between fishing pressure and climate forcing is analysed in this paper, using an end-to-end ecosystem model of the southern Benguela ecosystem, built from coupling hydrodynamic, biogeochemical and multispecies fish models (ROMS-N2P2Z2D2-OSMOSE). Scenarios of different intensities of upwelling-favourable wind stress combined with scenarios of fishing top-predator fish were tested. Analyses of isolated drivers show that the bottom-up effect of the climate forcing propagates up the food chain whereas the top-down effect of fishing cascades down to zooplankton in unfavourable environmental conditions but dampens before it reaches phytoplankton. When considering both climate and fishing drivers together, it appears that top-down control dominates the link between top-predator fish and forage fish, whereas interactions between the lower trophic levels are dominated by bottom-up control. The forage fish functional group appears to be a central component of this ecosystem, being the meeting point of two opposite trophic controls. The set of combined scenarios shows that fishing pressure and upwelling-favourable wind stress have mostly dampened effects on fish populations, compared to predictions from the separate effects of the stressors. Dampened effects result in biomass accumulation at the top predator fish level but a depletion of biomass at the forage fish level. This should draw our attention to the evolution of this functional group, which appears as both structurally important in the trophic functioning of the ecosystem, and very sensitive to climate and fishing pressures. In particular, diagnoses considering fishing pressure only might be more optimistic than those that consider combined effects of fishing and environmental variability.

Using ecological models to assess ecosystem status in support of the European Marine Strategy Framework Directive

“…This represents a powerful tool for scenario testing of climate change and anthropogenic impacts simultaneously. There is a growing trend for E2E modelling, which includes anthropogenic and physical drivers behind observed changes, identifying both direct and indirect causes (Fulton, 2010;Shin et al, 2010b;Travers-Trolet et al, 2014), and so better facilitates the setting of targets and implementation of management measures (Cury et al, 2008;Kaplan et al, 2012). Fig.…”

Historical changes of the Mediterranean Sea ecosystem: modelling the role and impact of primary productivity and fisheries changes over time

“…In recent years, under the growing need to provide guidance for biodiversity conservation and ecosystem based management, these so called end-to-end (E2E) models521 have been increasingly used to predict marine ecosystem changes and for scenario testing of climate change and anthropogenic impacts simultaneously2223.…”

Modeling the coastal ecosystem complex: present situation and challenges

“…OSMOSE has often been coupled with lower trophic level systems based on satellite chlorophyll a (Grüss et al 2015) and biogeochemical models (Halouani et al 2016;Travers-Trolet et al 2014). Travers-Trolet et al (2014) investigated the effects of the combined pressures of fishing and climate forcing in the southern Benguela ecosystem using a hydrodynamic lower trophic level OSMOSE-coupled model.…”

“…Travers-Trolet et al (2014) investigated the effects of the combined pressures of fishing and climate forcing in the southern Benguela ecosystem using a hydrodynamic lower trophic level OSMOSE-coupled model. This suggested important roles for intermediate trophic level foraging fish under the combined pressures.…”

“…IBMs coupled with hydrodynamic/biogeochemical models including NEMURO. FISH/SAN Rose et al 2015) and OSMOSE (Halouani et al 2016;Travers-Trolet et al 2014) have advantages in resolving life histories. Indeed, Rose et al (2015) modeled the entire life cycles of sardine and anchovy in the California Current System.…”