Combining Stakeholder- and Social Network- Analysis to Improve Regional Nature Conservation: A Case Study from Osnabrück, Germany

Abstract

Many nature conservation projects fail primarily not because of a lack of knowledge about upcoming threats or viable conservation concepts but rather because of the inability to transfer knowledge into the creation of effective measures. Therefore, an increase in information exchange and collaboration between theory- and practice-oriented conservation actors, as well as between conservation actors, land user groups, and authorities may enhance the effectiveness of conservation goals. By considering the interactions between conservation stakeholders as social networks, social network analysis (SNA) can help identify structural optimization potential in these networks. The present study combines SNA and stakeholder analysis (SA) to assess the interactions between 34 conservation stakeholders in the major city and district of Osnabrück in northwestern Germany and offers insights into cost/benefit optimizations of these stakeholder interactions. Data were acquired using a pile sort technique and guideline-based expert interviews. The SA, based on knowledge mapping and SWOT (strength, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats) analysis, identified individual stakeholder’s complementary properties, indicating which among them would most benefit from mutual information exchange and collaboration. The SNA revealed discrepancies in information exchange and collaboration between theory- and practice-focused stakeholders. Conflicts were found predominantly between conservation associations, authorities and land user groups. Ecological research, funding, land-use conflicts, and distribution of conservation knowledge were identified as fields with high potential for increased information exchange and collaboration. Interviews also showed that the stakeholders themselves see many opportunities for increased networking in the region. The results are discussed in relation to the existing literature on nature conservation networks and used to recommend optimization measures for the studied network. Finally, the conclusion reflects upon the developed approach’s implications and possibilities for conservation stakeholders and planners in general.

Investigating Stakeholders Networks; Case Study on Cidanau Watershed in Indonesia

“…The meaningful engagement of stakeholders, including local communities, government agencies, industries, and environmental organizations, plays a pivotal role in ensuring the success of watershed management initiatives. Inadequate involvement of these stakeholders can lead to a lack of ownership, limited support, and insufficient consideration of diverse perspectives and interests, underscoring the importance of their active participation [6,8]. The achievement of sustainable watershed management outcomes relies on the crucial elements of collaborative decision-making and active stakeholder participation [37].…”

“…Social network analysis (SNA) serves as a tool that enables the modeling, visualization, and analysis of interactions among individuals within groups and organizations [2][3][4]. Doing social network analysis requires tools to be able to process data so that it can be visualized and represented in a form that is easy to understand [5,6]. Technological advancements have directly and profoundly impacted the field of social network analysis, enabling the creation of comprehensive frameworks for social networking and automating the analysis of social networks [7,8].…”

Changes in Economic Network Patterns and Influencing Factors in the Urban Agglomeration of Guangdong–Hong Kong–Macao Greater Bay Area: A Comprehensive Study

“…These investigations have provided valuable insights into the structural characteristics of urban agglomeration evolution [30,31], urban network structure [32], urban network hierarchy [33], and interconnections between cities [34]. Social network analysis could also be utilized to quantify the connectivity and centrality of urban areas [35], identify primary driving forces [36], and demonstrate the effects and mutual influences among cities [37].…”

Social Network Analysis and Stakeholders’ Influence on Moringa Plant Development Potential in Mpwapwa District, Tanzania

“…Recent studies around the globe have explored the use of social network analysis to identify stakeholders' influence on Moringa plant (Moringa oleifera L. as well other related species) development potential Hermans et al, 2017;Przesdzink et al, 2022;Ramoroka et al, 2022). Moringa plant is a perennial softwood tree with a variety of potential uses , of which the nutritional and medicinal are considered the most.…”