Comparison of Masculine and Feminine Gender Roles in Iranian Patients with Gender Identity Disorder

Abstract

IntroductionGender identity disorders (GID) are heterogeneous disorders that may be influenced by culture and social norms.AimThe aim of this study was to determine masculine and feminine gender roles in a group of Iranian patients with GID and compare these roles with two control groups.MethodsTwelve male‐to‐female (MF) and 27 female‐to‐male (FM) individuals with GID referred to Tehran Psychiatric Institute in Tehran, I. R. Iran were evaluated by self‐report inventories and were compared with two groups of healthy controls (81 men and 89 women). Diagnoses were established based on the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, fourth edition (DSM‐IV) criteria. Data analysis was done using analysis of variance and chi‐squared test.Main Outcome MeasuresMasculine and feminine gender roles were assessed by two questionnaires: (i) Gender‐Masculine (GM) and Gender‐Feminine (GF) scales derived from the Minnesota Multiphasic Inventory‐2 (MMPI‐2); (ii) Bem Sex Role Inventory (BSRI).ResultsIn the scales of masculinity, MF‐GID individuals scored as male controls, but lower than female controls. FM‐GID individuals scored similar to female controls and higher than male controls. In femininity scales, MF‐GID individuals and control women seemed similar, and both scored higher than the other groups. FM‐GID persons were considered less feminine than both controls in the GF scale of MMPI‐2, but not in the BSRI. In both scales, FM‐GID persons had higher scores than control women and MF‐GID individuals.ConclusionIranian FM‐GID individuals were less feminine than normal men. However, MF‐GID individuals were similar to normal women or more feminine. Cultural considerations remain to be investigated. Alavi K, Eftekhar M and Jalali Nadoushan AH. Comparison of masculine and feminine gender roles in Iranian patients with gender identity disorder. Sex Med 2015;3:261–268.

Sexual and gender minority health in the Middle East and North Africa Region: A scoping review

“…In three studies in Iran, researchers compared gender roles between cisgender and transgender participants ( Alavi et al., 2015 ; Khorashad et al., 2019 ; Roshan et al., 2019 ). For example, Alavi and colleagues reported that compared to cisgender male and female participants, transgender participants had the highest and lowest score on the Gender Masculine scale, respectively; transgender men had the lowest score on the Gender Feminine scale of all groups ( Alavi et al., 2015 ).…”

High-risk Behaviors in Sex-Reassigned Trans-sexual People in Tehran, Iran

“…Laws have been passed that support sex reassignment in people with ambiguous sexual identification in Iran, but they are subject to a great deal of mental pressure due to cultural norms (14). There are no accurate statistics which sexual and also high-risk behaviors such as drug abuse in transsexual persons in Iran.…”