Conceptualising Sustainability Using a Cognitive Mapping Method

Abstract

Many different interpretations of the meaning of sustainability has the potential to cause dilution of meaning, as well as ambiguity and confusion, and a reduction in the use of sustainability as a relevant global objective. In this research, we examine these different interpretations using a cognitive mapping method, where 12 sustainability experts provide their own unique conceptualisations of sustainability. Our research objective is to develop a conceptual tool that explains differences in these many sustainability meanings. The experts’ conceptualisations reveal worldviews that are predominantly anthropocentric, but which also contain principles consistent with the sustaincentrism paradigm. We observe that each expert’s worldview, together with the assumed primary objective of sustainability, and the type of actions recommended to achieve sustainability, are central to understanding the diversity of sustainability conceptualisations. This insight leads to the development of a framework that infers sustainability can be conceptualised to consist of three distinct layers consisting of a core objective, or what is to be sustained; a worldview that underpins the conceptualisation; and actions aimed at achieving sustainability. By clarifying the multiple layers contained within sustainability conceptualisations, competing and contested versions of sustainability can be clarified within a common theoretical framework. The sustainability framework should also assist educators and students navigate through the multiplicity of sustainability meanings, and enable new context-specific definitions to be developed, such as those used in business and government.

Using Conceptual Mapping for Learning to Affect Students’ Motivation and Academic Achievement

“…The sustainability framework should also assist educators and students in navigating through the multiplicity of sustainability meanings [67]. Student and cohort learning in sustainable development is assessed using conceptual mapping [23].…”

“What It Means to be a Digital Citizen”: Using concept mapping and an educational game to explore children's conceptualization of digital citizenship

“…However, such an approach might be influenced by linguistic and communicative factors, and interfere with children's DGBL experience as well. Therefore, the 3CM approach was finally utilized to reveal participants' knowledge structure of DC, embodying assumptions, beliefs, “facts,” and misconceptions [ 55 , 56 ].…”

An Approach to the Perceptions of Spanish Consumers on Food Sustainability Through the Use of Projective Techniques

“…However, different studies point out that sustainable development is a contradictory concept due to the impossibility of maintaining infinite economic growth on a limited planet (Redclift, 2005;Sachs, 1999) and highlight the contradictions between their objectives (Spaiser et al, 2017). All this reveals that the debate on both concepts is still open and evidences the need to deepen the academic discussion on their meanings (Whyte and Lamberton, 2020).…”