Conflict or consensus: An investigation of stakeholder concerns during the participation process of major infrastructure and construction projects in Hong Kong

Abstract

a b s t r a c tPublic participation in the planning and design of major public infrastructure and construction (PIC) projects is crucial to their success, as the interests of different stakeholders can be systematically captured and built into the finalised scheme. However, public participation may not always yield a mutually acceptable solution, especially when the interests of stakeholders are diverse and conflicting. Confrontations and disputes can arise unless the concerns or needs of the community are carefully analysed and addressed. The aim of the paper is to propose a systematic method of analysing stakeholder concerns relating to PIC projects by examining the degree of consensus and/or conflict involved. The results of a questionnaire survey and a series of interviews with different entities are provided, which indicate the existence of a significant divergence of views among stakeholder groups and that conflicts arise when there is a mismatch between peoples' perception concerning money and happiness on the one hand and development and damages on the other. Policy and decision-makers should strive to resolve at least the majority of conflicts that arise throughout the lifecycle of major PIC projects so as to maximise their chance of success.

Who should take the responsibility? Stakeholders' power over social responsibility issues in construction projects

“…Stakeholders' power over social responsibility issues in construction projects, Journal promote SR is still inadequate. Li et al (2012) found that the public in eastern culture countries is less likely to engage in project decision-making owning to the traditional culture of compliance. It calls for a development of communication channels or stakeholder platforms for project users to put forwards their demands.…”

“…It is commonly agreed that stakeholders have conflicting interests on project objectives (Atkin and Skitmore, 2008). The empirical findings by Li et al (2012) show that the general public care most about land use and environmental issues and that governments focus mainly on economic growth, while NGOs value the green and sustainable techniques most. Having an interest does not necessarily mean having the ability to accomplish the goals.…”

Stakeholders’ Expectations in Urban Renewal Projects in China: A Key Step towards Sustainability

“…As one of the most commonly accepted definitions, stakeholders refer to the individuals or groups that can influence or be affected by the urban renewal process [66][67][68]. Those individuals or groups have their own stake or interest in urban renewal projects.…”

A Context-based Procedure for Assessing Participatory Schemes in Environmental Planning

“…Weighting scales can be constructed for each stakeholder by using ordinal information from 527 the survey in order to state whether a particular aspect is equally, more or less important than 528 another for a given stakeholder (as in Li et al, 2012). For example, decisive and irreversible 529 votes have more weight than oral statements, even the more so when the latter are not 530 repeated or confirmed by subsequent actions.…”