“…Since J has no critical points in Σ + , it follows from [14,Proposition 7.24 and Theorem 8.2], that J c 1 = {u ∈ Σ + | J (u) c 1 } retract by deformation onto X ∞ = W u (y 1 ) ∞ ∪ W u (y 0 ) ∞ , which can be parameterized by X × [A, +∞[. Now, we claim that X ∞ is contractible in J c 1 Since H (x) H (y 1 ) for any x ∈ X, it follows from the above estimates that J (f (t, x, λ)) < c 1 for any (t, x, λ) ∈ [0, 1] × X × [A, ∞[.…”