Cytoreductive therapy is not routinely recommended for younger patients with polycythemia vera (PV) due to concern that treatment toxicity may outweigh therapeutic benefits. However, no systematic data supports this approach. To support objective risk/benefit assessment of cytoreductive drugs in PV patients younger than 60 (PV<60), this systematic review and meta-analysis was conducted to evaluate toxicity and disease-related complications in PV<60 treated with interferon alfa (rIFNα) or hydroxyurea (HU). A search of PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science and Embase identified 693 unique studies with relevant keywords, of which 14 met inclusion criteria and were selected for analysis. The weighted average age of patients treated with rIFNα was 48 years (n=744 patients, 12 studies) and for HU was 56 years (n=1397, 8 studies). The weighted average duration of treatment for either drug was 4.5 years. Using a Bayesian hierarchical model, the pooled annual rate of discontinuation due to toxicity was 5.2% (n=587, CI 2.2%-8.2%) for patients receiving rIFNα, and 3.6% (n=1097, CI 1%-6.2%) for HU. The average complete hematologic response (CHR) for rIFNα and HU was 62% and 52%, respectively. Patients experienced thrombotic events at a pooled annual rate of 0.79% and 1.26%; sMF at 1.06% and 1.62%; AML at 0.14% and 0.26%; and death at 0.87% and 2.65%, respectively. No treatment-related deaths were reported. With acceptable rates of non-fatal toxicity, cytoreductive treatment, particularly with disease-modifying rIFNα, may benefit PV<60. Future randomized trials prioritizing inclusion of PV<60 are needed to establish a long-term benefit of early cytoreductive treatment in these patients.