Creating effective interrupted time series graphs: Review and recommendations

Abstract

Introduction: Interrupted Time Series (ITS) studies may be used to assess the impact of an interruption, such as an intervention or exposure. The data from such studies are particularly amenable to visual display and, when clearly depicted, can readily show the short-and long-term impact of an interruption. Further, wellconstructed graphs allow data to be extracted using digitizing software, which can facilitate their inclusion in systematic reviews and meta-analyses. Aim: We provide recommendations for graphing ITS data, examine the properties of plots presented in ITS studies, and provide examples employing our recommendations. Methods and results: Graphing recommendations from seminal data visualization resources were adapted for use with ITS studies. The adapted recommendations cover plotting of data points, trend lines, interruptions, additional lines and general graph components. We assessed whether 217 graphs from recently published (2013-2017) ITS studies met our recommendations and found that 130 graphs (60%) had clearly distinct data points, 100 (46%) had trend lines, and 161 (74%) had a clearly defined interruption. Accurate data extraction (requiring distinct points that align with axis tick marks and labels that allow the points to be interpreted) was possible in only 72 (33%) graphs. Conclusion: We found that many ITS graphs did not meet our recommendations and could be improved with simple changes. Our proposed recommendations aim to achieve greater standardization and improvement in the display of ITS data, and facilitate re-use of the data in systematic reviews and metaanalyses.

Abortion Safety and Use with Normally Prescribed Mifepristone in Canada

“…13 We graphed the observed and expected monthly outcome incidence (quarterly for outcomes with <6 events in any month) following best practices. 21 We estimated risk differences and risk ratios for each outcome by comparing the observed with expected values for September 2019, a time point selected a priori to balance model stability (greatest in the middle of the study period) and integration of mifepristone into practice (greatest at the end of the study period). We used bootstrapping with 200 samples drawn with replacement to estimate 95% confidence intervals 22 without adjustment for multiple comparisons.…”

The effects of an evidence- and theory-informed feedback intervention on opioid prescribing for non-cancer pain in primary care: A controlled interrupted time series analysis

“…We adhered to current reporting recommendations for ITS [35][36][37]. Our statistical analysis plan is provided (S7 Text).…”

Development, piloting, and evaluation of an evidence-based informed consent form for total knee arthroplasty (EvAb-Pilot): a protocol for a mixed methods study

“…As we will conduct an explorative pilot study, we will not perform a test for statistically significant differences. We will prepare interrupted-time-series graphs to visualize the results [49]. All analyses will be performed using SAS software [50] and R [51].…”