Dealing with landscape fuzziness in user preference studies: Photo-based questionnaires in the Mediterranean context

Abstract

a b s t r a c tMediterranean landscapes reveal extremely adequate conditions for the development of other functions besides production (nature conservation, recreation, life quality, local identity). These functions support the provision of public goods and services increasingly recognized by society. With this goal, the production of knowledge that may support decision is highly needed. In Mediterranean extensively used areas, the analysis of landscape features and related public preferences is complex, as the landscape pattern is highly fuzzy and land cover classes are often mixed. Resulting from multiple research developments, this paper demonstrates how photo-based surveys can be a suitable tool for assessing landscape preferences by specific public groups. Landscape functions addressed are closely linked to land cover patterns, as resulting from land cover systems. Thus using photographs in landscape questionnaires is useful in focusing the discussion on specific aspects, related with the variations in land cover and in their combinations with other specific landscape features. But the photos shown need to be clear and easily perceivable by the respondents. In order to cope with the underlying fuzziness of these landscapes, manipulation of images has been developed as the best solution so that the variations shown to respondents are adequately controlled in the study and landscape features are easily recognized by the respondents. The methodological approach as well as the results of applied approaches, of two studies on the users preferences, applied to a case-study area in Alentejo region, Portugal, are presented. The issues concerned with photo manipulation are a particular focus of discussion.

Use of Video and 3D Scenario Visualisation to Rate Vegetation Screens for Integrating Buildings into the Landscape

“…A high degree of realism is the main advantage of this approach, although the output is not interactive [12,13].…”

Public Support for Wetland Restoration: What is the Link With Ecosystem Service Values?

“…While landscape visualizations are commonly used in landscape preference studies (Kohsaka and Flitner 2004;Dramstad et al 2006;Lange et al 2008;Arnberger and Eder 2011;Barroso et al 2012), they are less often used in ES studies. When the goal of the research is to elucidate general environmental values this does not have to be problematic, but in the case of ESs, researchers are often interested in assigned values, related to specific ecosystem and/or landscape types.…”

Semantic Assessments of Experienced Biodiversity from Photographs and On-Site Observations – A Comparison

“…This applies to the construction or expansions of roads, dams, tourist facilities, etc., and its impact on, inter alia, noise and biodiversity. Such studies usually include questionnaires based on photos (Barroso, Pinto-Correia, Ramos, Surová, & Menezes, 2012;Pinto-Correia et al, 2013;Sherren et al, 2011;Tveit, 2009). …”